On Jul 28, 5:13 pm, sina.tootoon...@gmail.com wrote:> hi folks, > > Is there any literature out there analyzing the effects of running > simple peak detection algorithms on different classes of signals? I've > found peak detection to be a very useful operation in my DSP work, and > a web search returns many links to algorithms that perform this > operation, but (perhaps due to its nonlinearity) I haven't been able > to find any papers describing the mathematical properties of the peak > detection operation. I understand that peak detection is a bit of a > black art and no general results may exist, but I'd appreciate any > pointers to even highly simplified cases. > > Thanks, > > SinaPeak detection is described in literature as an 'order statistic' and in spectrum analysis literature as 'ORing' or 'OR-ing'. In spectrum analysis peak picking has often been used to compress data for display. There is some literature available at: http://stinet.dtic.mil/ Such as: Detection Performance of Or-ing Device with Pre- and Post-Averaging: Part II- Phase-Incoherent Signal http://www.dtic.mil/srch/d...8F23681120DB&id=ADA370787 This document is part of a 4 part series by Albert Nuttall, available from DTIC by searching at the above site.. Dale B. Dalrymple http://dbdimages.com
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
peak detection literature
Started by ●July 28, 2008
Reply by ●July 30, 20082008-07-30
Reply by ●July 30, 20082008-07-30
On Jul 29, 8:54 am, julius <juli...@gmail.com> wrote:> On Jul 29, 9:49 am, sina.tootoon...@gmail.com wrote: > > > Hi Julius, > > > I didn't have a particular application in mind. I've used peak > > detection for different reasons in the past e.g. to distinguish > > different signal categories in a recording, and have found it to work > > quite well. However since I haven't come across any general > > characterizations of the PD operation, I've always felt a little > > uneasy using it since I can't say anything more rigorous than 'it > > seems to work well on my test signals' to justify my using it. > > > - Sina > > Are you saying that you are using peak detection to discriminate > between different audio signals? Well, the effectiveness depends > first of all on what classifications you want to make. If I were you, > I'd forget all about peak detection, think about how you would > describe the signal classes you are trying to discriminate, and > then see what the best method is. > > Sounds like you have a hammer you have been using, and you > are not sure what a nail looks like :-). Maybe you should now > look at how a nail really looks like, and then see if a hammer is > the correct tool for it. > > Cheers, > JuliusI agree with your point about nail characterization. However, e.g. in the signal characterization case I mentioned above, I found that characterizing the signals in (peak time, peak voltage) space made them easier to distinguish than in the ordinary time domain. But since I couldn't find any literature on the properties of this transformation, I didn't pursue it further. -Sina
Reply by ●July 30, 20082008-07-30
On Jul 30, 7:03 am, dbd <d...@ieee.org> wrote:> On Jul 28, 5:13 pm, sina.tootoon...@gmail.com wrote: > > > hi folks, > > > Is there any literature out there analyzing the effects of running > > simple peak detection algorithms on different classes of signals? I've > > found peak detection to be a very useful operation in my DSP work, and > > a web search returns many links to algorithms that perform this > > operation, but (perhaps due to its nonlinearity) I haven't been able > > to find any papers describing the mathematical properties of the peak > > detection operation. I understand that peak detection is a bit of a > > black art and no general results may exist, but I'd appreciate any > > pointers to even highly simplified cases. > > > Thanks, > > > Sina > > Peak detection is described in literature as an 'order statistic' and > in spectrum analysis literature as 'ORing' or 'OR-ing'. In spectrum > analysis peak picking has often been used to compress data for > display. There is some literature available at: > > http://stinet.dtic.mil/ > > Such as: > Detection Performance of Or-ing Device with Pre- and Post-Averaging: > Part II- Phase-Incoherent Signalhttp://www.dtic.mil/srch/d...8F23681120DB&id=ADA370787 > > This document is part of a 4 part series by Albert Nuttall, available > from DTIC by searching at the above site.. > > Dale B. Dalrymplehttp://dbdimages.comThanks Dale, this sounds like exactly what I was looking for. The second link you posted appears to be broken, but I'm sure I can use the rest of the information to track down the articles you suggested. - Sina







