On May 19, 10:48�am, Eric Jacobsen <eric.jacob...@ieee.org> wrote:> On 5/18/2010 5:52 PM, Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote: > > > > > > > > > Rick Lyons wrote: > > >> Hi Guys, > >> here's a thought for those of you who are consultants, or work for > >> small companies doing consulting work. > >> The next time your potential customer comments in a negative way about > >> your consulting fee, consider saying the following to your customer: > > >> "Yes, professionals are expensive. However, try doing the job with > >> amateurs." > > > I'd say something is not right if it comes down to that kind of whoring. > > Normally, they don't negotiate with doctors, lawyers or consultants. > > Either the price is set way over reasonable, or the prospect has no > > realistic idea how much is the cost for this kind of work. > > > Vladimir Vassilevsky > > DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant > >http://www.abvolt.com > > Actually, it's not unusual or unheard of to negotiate prices with > doctors, lawyers, and consultants. � Especially these days. > > One of the more disappointing things I see, unfortunately regularly, is > when we get turned down for being "too expensive" and then get called > back in later (or not) to fix some money-and-time-sucking disaster that > was attempted to be done with less cost. �You can't ever really say, "I > told you so", but it makes me cringe to see 3x the money thrown at > something over 3x the time it should have taken on a job we lost because > we were "too expensive". > > -- > Eric Jacobsen > Minister of Algorithms > Abineau Communicationshttp://www.abineau.com- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text -I was discussing with a friend just last night about a contract where he estimated a year. The client said they don't have that long and went away. Now they come back to him after screwing around their own for 6 months and want him to fix it in the remaining 6 months of his original estimate. What Fun! I like the sign in mechanic's shops that say labor $75/hour ----- $150/hour if you watch. Clay
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
A suggestion for DSP consultants
Started by ●May 18, 2010
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On 5/19/2010 10:56 AM, Clay wrote:> On May 19, 10:48 am, Eric Jacobsen<eric.jacob...@ieee.org> wrote: >> On 5/18/2010 5:52 PM, Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote: >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >>> Rick Lyons wrote: >> >>>> Hi Guys, >>>> here's a thought for those of you who are consultants, or work for >>>> small companies doing consulting work. >>>> The next time your potential customer comments in a negative way about >>>> your consulting fee, consider saying the following to your customer: >> >>>> "Yes, professionals are expensive. However, try doing the job with >>>> amateurs." >> >>> I'd say something is not right if it comes down to that kind of whoring. >>> Normally, they don't negotiate with doctors, lawyers or consultants. >>> Either the price is set way over reasonable, or the prospect has no >>> realistic idea how much is the cost for this kind of work. >> >>> Vladimir Vassilevsky >>> DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant >>> http://www.abvolt.com >> >> Actually, it's not unusual or unheard of to negotiate prices with >> doctors, lawyers, and consultants. Especially these days. >> >> One of the more disappointing things I see, unfortunately regularly, is >> when we get turned down for being "too expensive" and then get called >> back in later (or not) to fix some money-and-time-sucking disaster that >> was attempted to be done with less cost. You can't ever really say, "I >> told you so", but it makes me cringe to see 3x the money thrown at >> something over 3x the time it should have taken on a job we lost because >> we were "too expensive". >> >> -- >> Eric Jacobsen >> Minister of Algorithms >> Abineau Communicationshttp://www.abineau.com- Hide quoted text - >> >> - Show quoted text - > > I was discussing with a friend just last night about a contract where > he estimated a year. The client said they don't have that long and > went away. Now they come back to him after screwing around their own > for 6 months and want him to fix it in the remaining 6 months of his > original estimate. What Fun!Sometimes it's the other way around. Back before GUIs made it out od PARC, a businessman wanted me to write an interactive program that his clients could use for self assessment. He did a creditable job of describing how he wanted it to work, but without a firm spec it was still arm waving. I told him that I couldn't estimate the job without a contractual way to know when it was finished and I'd earned my fee. When he said that he hadn't the time to write a detailed requirements document, I asked if he intended to write the instruction manual himself. When he said that the manual was his job, I suggested that he write it first and I would turn it into reality. When my program implemented the manual, I got paid. Any changes after that were negotiable extras. He said he's think about it, but I heard nothing for several months. Then I got a modest check in the mail. When I called his office to say that there had been a mistake, his secretary told me that she sure there was none, and that The Boss was out of town. She agreed that he's call me when he returned. He explained that he didn't want to be embarrassed by writing up things that couldn't be done, so he coded little snippets as he wrote pieces of the manual. He coded more to convince (or dissuade) himself that a particular approach made sense. By the time the manual was finished, most of the code (in BASIC yet!) was too. He thanked me for the discipline that writing the manual provided, and said that doing it had made him realize just how nebulous his ideas had been when we talked. He said that he was paying me not as a programmer, but as a consultant. Jerry -- "I view the progress of science as ... the slow erosion of the tendency to dichotomize." --Barbara Smuts, U. Mich. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On May 19, 9:45�am, Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote:> > Unfortunately many link the term "amateur" to also mean lower quality > or lessor ability. And certainly some amateurs are just starting out, > so their skills and knowledge would not compare with a pro's. But some > amateurs have very advanced skills and experienced pros recognize > this. >Consider the difference between a minister (as in a church) and an ordinary person with high moral standards. One is paid to be good (a professional) while the other is good for nothing....
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
Clay wrote:> On May 18, 8:52 pm, Vladimir Vassilevsky <nos...@nowhere.com> wrote: >> Rick Lyons wrote: >>> Hi Guys, >>> here's a thought for those of you who are consultants, >>> or work for small companies doing consulting work. >>> The next time your potential customer comments in a >>> negative way about your consulting fee, consider saying >>> the following to your customer: >>> "Yes, professionals are expensive. However, try >>> doing the job with amateurs." >> I'd say something is not right if it comes down to that kind of whoring. >> Normally, they don't negotiate with doctors, lawyers or consultants. >> Either the price is set way over reasonable, or the prospect has no >> realistic idea how much is the cost for this kind of work. >> >> Vladimir Vassilevsky >> DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultanthttp://www.abvolt.com > > Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he > likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower. But my > experience is the client also often needs some special knowledge or > skill that you can provide. A few times I had someone want something > complex for a ridiculusly cheap price. Those kinds of deals just can't > go forward. Better clients listen to you, and you work out a deal with > them.The "want something complex for a ridiculously low price" folks fall into two camps, too. The better kind (for me) are the ones where you can gently explain the complexity and why it's going to take a long time and they listen and understand. Sometimes they come back with enough resources to engage me. The worse kind are the ones who just want a free lunch, or who desperately need talent but can't trust it -- those are just cause for a shrug, and thankfulness at the escape. -- Tim Wescott Control system and signal processing consulting www.wescottdesign.com
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On 5/19/2010 11:38 AM, dvsarwate wrote:> On May 19, 9:45 am, Clay<c...@claysturner.com> wrote: >> >> Unfortunately many link the term "amateur" to also mean lower quality >> or lessor ability. And certainly some amateurs are just starting out, >> so their skills and knowledge would not compare with a pro's. But some >> amateurs have very advanced skills and experienced pros recognize >> this. >> > > Consider the difference between a minister (as in a church) > and an ordinary person with high moral standards. One is > paid to be good (a professional) while the other is good > for nothing....Dilip, I take it that you're familiar with the half-sandwich fallacy. Jerry -- "I view the progress of science as ... the slow erosion of the tendency to dichotomize." --Barbara Smuts, U. Mich. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On Wed, 19 May 2010 07:26:00 -0700 (PDT), Clay <clay@claysturner.com> wrote:>Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he >likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower.And then there is the client who THINKS he knows how to do it (but really doesn't), and is simply short of manpower. Those gigs can be nightmares. Greg
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On 19 Mai, 19:08, Greg Berchin <gberc...@comicast.net.invalid> wrote:> On Wed, 19 May 2010 07:26:00 -0700 (PDT), Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote: > >Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he > >likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower. > > And then there is the client who THINKS he knows how to do it (but really > doesn't), and is simply short of manpower. �Those gigs can be nightmares.Wring. Those jobs *are* nightmares. Carreer ending, even, for whatever engineer ends up getting involved. The trick is to recognize those things ASAP, and then walk away. Rune
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
Rune Allnor wrote:> On 19 Mai, 19:08, Greg Berchin <gberc...@comicast.net.invalid> wrote: >> On Wed, 19 May 2010 07:26:00 -0700 (PDT), Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote: >>> Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he >>> likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower. >> And then there is the client who THINKS he knows how to do it (but really >> doesn't), and is simply short of manpower. Those gigs can be nightmares. > > Wring. Those jobs *are* nightmares. Carreer ending, even, for > whatever > engineer ends up getting involved.Not necessarily, at least not in the US. Particularly if the company in question has developed a reputation for that sort of hubris with other managers in the area.> The trick is to recognize those things ASAP, and then walk away.Or give one go at explaining to the client why they don't really know -- then if they can't accept it, you walk away as cordially as possible. -- Tim Wescott Control system and signal processing consulting www.wescottdesign.com
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On 19 Mai, 16:26, Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote:> Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he > likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower.A perverted variation of this is when the client doesn't know how to do things, but are under the impression that the employee knows (a consultant would wak straigt away from those kinds of things). It has happened to me on a number of occasions that some idiot / amateur / dillettante I happened to work for made insane appointments on my behalf. When I walk away, the question is usually dropped 'for lack of manpower.'> But my > experience is the client also often needs some special knowledge or > skill that you can provide.I have experienced that kind of thing exactly once over the past 20 years. Somebody approached me with a project where some professor had been involved as consultant for some time, but where the system just did not work. The client knew I had some experience with remote sensing, and asked me to sit in on a meeting with the prof to find out what the heck was going on. I figurd out that the guy made 'blunders' and 'flaws' (I suspect deliberate omissions) on a level a high-school student would catch, and reported this back to the client. My client dropped the project at the blink of an eye. The one mistake I did in that project was to *not* explicitly suggest to my client that they consulted legal expertice to evaluate whether questions ought to be asked about whether the prof was liable of fraud or professional misconduct. The somewhat more fun part was that the client hired me to come up with an alternative approach to do the same measurement. From a purely technical perspective the project was a success. The problem was that our solution did not fit in with the operational constraints at my client's business. Oh well. Rune
Reply by ●May 19, 20102010-05-19
On 19 Mai, 19:22, Tim Wescott <t...@seemywebsite.now> wrote:> Rune Allnor wrote: > > On 19 Mai, 19:08, Greg Berchin <gberc...@comicast.net.invalid> wrote: > >> On Wed, 19 May 2010 07:26:00 -0700 (PDT), Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote: > >>> Another thing is to remember if the client knows how to do it, he > >>> likely doesn't need you unless he is simply short of manpower. > >> And then there is the client who THINKS he knows how to do it (but really > >> doesn't), and is simply short of manpower. �Those gigs can be nightmares. > > > Wring. Those jobs *are* nightmares. Carreer ending, even, for > > whatever > > engineer ends up getting involved. > > Not necessarily, at least not in the US. �Particularly if the company in > question has developed a reputation for that sort of hubris with other > managers in the area.There are a number of deficiencies in the Norwegian 'national character': - From the olden days there is a saying that 'Den Gud gir embete gir han ogs� forstand'. My translation: 'Whom God gives office, he also gives brains' - Not quite so old: 'Nordmenn er f�dt med ski p� beina' - 'Norwegians wear skis as they are born' - And the really disastrous one, said by then PM Brundtland some time in the early '90s: 'Det er typisk norsk � v�re god'. This last one can be interpret in two ways: 'It is typical [of the] Norwegian [national character] to be good' or 'It is typical [for] Norwegian [citicens] to excel [in anything they attempt to do].' The common theme of these sayings and statements, which is so essential Norwegian character, is the *anti* merithocratic attitude. There is no need to try and learn anything, or to acquire skills or knowledge. They are either already there, as a matter of birth right, or they don't matter. Last week I even heard a Norwegian 'teacher' argue in support of grading technically illiterate high-school graduates with 'pass' if they were able to recognize traffic pictograms. 'We won't take away their right to higher education by giving them 'fail' grades.' It's lightyears beyong ridiculous! Not surprising, then, that one of the key figures in Norwegian folklore is Espen Askeladd, who is the lazy 'ladd' (=bugger) who prefer to sit near the fireplace (aske = ash) while everybody else works their asses off. Espen's two brothers tend to make the real effort to gain the prizes offered in the stories, and are universally punished. Espen flows by on his charm and cheeky attidtude, does nothing of actual value, but none the less ends up winning the princess and half the kingdom. And yes, these stories *do* preceed the present Royal household by several centuries... These are the defining traits of the Norwegian 'national soul'. So the Norwegian R&D institutes have no ambitions on their own but instead rely on everybody else to do the hard work. The key point in the Norwegian parasitic R&D philosophy is that we Norwegians are considered to be so 'nice' by these others, that we get their hard-earned results more or less for free. You won't see these kinds of things be mentioned in official statements, but talk with any Norwegian 'researcher' for more than ten minutes, and you ought to get him or her to admit more or less openly to this strategy. The people who advance and get promoted in this kind of system are the ones that subscribe to the underlying attitude. Which, of course, are the ones that are unable to take a stand, make an argument or come up with a non-PC view in any way, shape, form, sort or manner whatsoever. Which, of course, means that the few people who *do* have half a clue about whatever they might be talking about, tend to have a very hard time. Rune







