On Apr 3, 9:56�pm, Randy Yates <ya...@ieee.org> wrote:> On 04/02/2011 09:55 PM, robert bristow-johnson wrote: >...> > the fact that the result of a measurement is inevitably an element of > > a finite set (i guess that set would be the rational numbers in a > > finite range) does not deprive such a result of having an operational > > status. > > > There are an infinite number of rational numbers in a finite range! >you are absolutely right, Randy. i was thinking "countable" (the set of reals, even in a finite range, is uncountably infinite).> And what the hell is an "operational status"?!?it basically means, as best as i can tell from physicists, that it's something that actually makes a difference. here's another example: there are physicists and cosmologists that have theories of a time- varying speed of light or varying G (perhaps even a varying hbar or epsilon_0). slowly time-varying, but varying nonetheless. they use such to try to explain problems we have today regarding the inflation of the universe and some other stuff. but there are other physicists (like Michael Duff) who say that the concept of a varying *dimensionful* constant is "not operationally meaningful" - meaning that we couldn't tell the difference, that nothing different would be noticed or measured in reality. now, to argue about what really *is* reality becomes an "how many angels can dance on a pinhead" sorta argument. but once we set aside the sophistry and accept that this reality we see and experience in our lives is real (that we are not just a cosmic computer simulation that *thinks* we are these physical beings with sentience and will and choice and feelings) then the issue of *quantity* of various physical things (length, mass, time, charge, and derived from those would be speed, energy, force, voltage, etc.) is not just an abstraction, but is *operational*. the more charge you toss onto a capacitor, the more energy is required to put additional charge on it, meaning more voltage. this quantity of *real* stuff is what real numbers are about. saying "more" or "less" means that these numbers representing physical quantity is ordered. and there are no real numbers that, when squared, result in real numbers that are negative. i'll get to illy's whackings after i read it. L8r, r b-j
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
Calibrating FFT results, amplitude in to magnitude out
Started by ●March 25, 2011
Reply by ●April 4, 20112011-04-04
Reply by ●April 5, 20112011-04-05
On Fri, 1 Apr 2011 10:32:29 -0700 (PDT), robert bristow-johnson
<rbj@audioimagination.com> wrote:
[Snipped by Lyons]
>i think a better term would be "comprehensive numbers". these numbers
>have everything they need, a real and imaginary component, either
>component can be negative or not, an integer or not, rational or
>irrational.
Hi Robert,
yes, "complex numbers" is an unfortunate term.
The great electrical engineer Charles Proteus Steinmetz
(who pioneered the analysis of transformers and
alternating current in the late 1800s) preferred to
use the phrase "general numbers" for what we today
call "complex numbers."
See Ya',
[-Rick-]
Reply by ●April 5, 20112011-04-05
Steinmetz's involvement with AC was at least as far-reaching ad Hertz's. The unit of frequency should have been named the after him. Specifically, using his initials. Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get.
Reply by ●April 5, 20112011-04-05
On Tue, 5 Apr 2011 06:18:16 -0700 (PDT), Jerry Avins <jya@ieee.org> wrote:>Steinmetz's involvement with AC was at least as far-reaching ad Hertz's. The unit of frequency should have been named the after him. Specifically, using his initials. > >Jerrylol...eons ago at my first engineering job my boss pulled out a conversion chart he had that they'd hand out to confused people to help convert from cps to Hz. One axis was on a log scale. I like stuff like that. ;) Eric Jacobsen http://www.ericjacobsen.org http://www.dsprelated.com/blogs-1//Eric_Jacobsen.php
Reply by ●May 3, 20112011-05-03
Hey Jerry, No, I haven't forgotten about this... On 03/30/2011 09:37 PM, Jerry Avins wrote:> On Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:12:57 AM UTC-4, Randy Yates wrote: >> On 03/28/2011 11:38 PM, Jerry Avins wrote: > > ... > >> Yeah. >> >>> And so on, until complex numbers are defined. >> >> It's the "and so on" which I think you're missing.> I'll repeat the litany and fill in the "and- so on"s. The counting > numbers are the strictly positive integers. If two are added, the > result is another counting number, so I call that operation "closed" > on the set of counting numbers. If I subtract a counting number from > another that is not greater than it, the result is not a counting > number. Subtraction does not closed with this set.> Digression. You say that subtraction and division are not > operations, but inverses of other operations.If I did, I did not correctly express myself. It is not the operations that are inverses, but rather that there are inverse elements, i.e., that the set the "addition" operation is defined on contains inverse elements.> You may certainly choose to define them that way, but the choice is > not forced. They are actually a bit unusual. Operand order is > immaterial for the "forward" operations, but for your inverses, > order is critical. A constraint has been added, so I ask, inverse of > what?An element c is defined as an inverse of element b iff b + c = e, where e is the identity element. We denote the inverse of b as -b. So in "normal" subtraction, a - b = a + -b. But this is just basic group theory and notations.> If the set of counting numbers is expanded by including zero and > negative numbers, it becomes the set of real integers."Real integers" is an oxymoron, in mathematics terms. The set is either real or integer; different beasts (although one is a subset of the other). So you just should be writing "integers." Just nits - I'm following your points though.> Subtraction closes on the set of real integers, i.e. the difference > of any two real integers is another real integer.> A product of two integers is also an integer, but a quotient is not. > To make division close on our set of numbers, we need to include > rational fractions.> Since we can multiply, we can also square ans raise to other powers. > That leads us to seek roots. (Roots are truly an inverse, because > there is only one argument.) To arrange that the operation of taking > a root close, the set of numbers has to be expanded to include > irrationals, and also (but not so obviously) complex numbers. The > even-powered root of a negative number requires imaginary numbers. > Roots of imaginaries reqire complex numbers. So with the inclusion > of complex numbers, all arithmetic operations close on all entities > we call numbers.Nicely put. I agree, using the terms and notions you've defined.> There are other ways to deal with these difficulties. For example, > we can avoid the need for negative integers if we create the rule > that whenever the subtrahend is not smaller than the minuend, we > reverse the order of the operands and write the difference with red > ink. (We still need zero.) The overriding advantage of using a > complete set of numbers and accepting the resuls as they come is > that there are no conditional operations.>>> Then _all_ arithmetic operations close.>> Really? What operations are you referring to? A field only has two >> operations: addition and multiplication.> No law of nature requires that we define it that way. Besides, what > kind of inverse operation has more conditions than the original?>> There is no such operations as >> subtraction and division. This is the role of *inverses* in >> algebra.> I thought I was discussing arithmetic.>> The reals have all the nice properties you are intimating >> (translating inverses to the other two operations). So why can't >> they be the zero of any arbitrary polynomial over the reals?> I don't know enough to discuss that intelligently.> JerryJerry, I believe, if I understand you correctly, the umbrella point you're making through all this is that you can choose to define (and work with) things in different ways. That I agree 100 percent with. However, if you are going another step and maintaining that the only difference between different respresentations, or notions, of the various arithmetic systems is the ease of use (e.g., complex arithmetic makes it easier to write a product), then I would disagree. The method of interpretation we call "abstract algebra" (groups, rings, fields, integral domains, Euclidean domains, Galois theory, etc.) is amazingly rich in results, or "fruit." For example: 1. The proof that a polynomial of degree higher than 4 cannot be factored systematically. 2. The fundamental theorem of arithmetic. 3. The overlap of abstract algebra with linear algebra via vector spaces. and many others. Like a human being, I judge an area of mathematics based on its fruits, and abstract algebra has been exceedingly fruitful. That is not to say that, as relativity superceded Newtonian physics, there is not something better, so you're right in that this interpretation isn't necessarily the only "right" one. However, I contend that the more fruit it bears, the "righter" it is. -- Randy Yates % "So now it's getting late, Digital Signal Labs % and those who hesitate mailto://yates@ieee.org % got no one..." http://www.digitalsignallabs.com % 'Waterfall', *Face The Music*, ELO
Reply by ●May 3, 20112011-05-03
On 05/03/2011 08:40 PM, Randy Yates wrote:> [...] > 2. The fundamental theorem of arithmetic.Correction: The fundamental theorem of algebra. -- Randy Yates % "So now it's getting late, Digital Signal Labs % and those who hesitate mailto://yates@ieee.org % got no one..." http://www.digitalsignallabs.com % 'Waterfall', *Face The Music*, ELO
Reply by ●May 4, 20112011-05-04
On May 3, 8:44�pm, Randy Yates <ya...@ieee.org> wrote:> On 05/03/2011 08:40 PM, Randy Yates wrote: > > > [...] > > 2. The fundamental theorem of arithmetic. > > Correction: The fundamental theorem of algebra. > -- > Randy Yates � � � � � � � � � � �% "So now it's getting late, > Digital Signal Labs � � � � � � �% � �and those who hesitate > mailto://ya...@ieee.org � � � � �% � �got no one..."http://www.digitalsignallabs.com% 'Waterfall', *Face The Music*, ELORandy, I'll have to respond another time. It's nearly midnight and I just got home. Thanks for the thoughtful post. Jerry -- Review of the Tates GPS: "He who has a Tates is lost."
Reply by ●May 4, 20112011-05-04
On May 3, 8:40�pm, Randy Yates <ya...@ieee.org> wrote:> Hey Jerry, > > No, I haven't forgotten about this... > > On 03/30/2011 09:37 PM, Jerry Avins wrote: > > > > > > > On Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:12:57 AM UTC-4, Randy Yates wrote: > >> On 03/28/2011 11:38 PM, Jerry Avins wrote: > > > � �... > > >> Yeah. > > >>> And so on, until complex numbers are defined. > > >> It's the "and so on" which I think you're missing. > > I'll repeat the litany and fill in the "and- so on"s. The counting > > numbers are the strictly positive integers. If two are added, the > > result is another counting number, so I call that operation "closed" > > on the set of counting numbers. If I subtract a counting number from > > another that is not greater than it, the result is not a counting > > number. Subtraction does not closed with this set. > > Digression. You say that subtraction and division are not > > operations, but inverses of other operations. > > If I did, I did not correctly express myself. It is not the operations > that are inverses, but rather that there are inverse elements, i.e., > that the set the "addition" operation is defined on contains inverse > elements. > > > You may certainly choose to define them that way, but the choice is > > not forced. They are actually a bit unusual. Operand order is > > immaterial for the "forward" operations, but for your inverses, > > order is critical. A constraint has been added, so I ask, inverse of > > what? > > An element c is defined as an inverse of element b iff b + c = e, > where e is the identity element. We denote the inverse of b as > -b. So in "normal" subtraction, a - b = a + -b. > > But this is just basic group theory and notations. > > > If the set of counting numbers is expanded by including zero and > > negative numbers, it becomes the set of real integers. > > "Real integers" is an oxymoron, in mathematics terms. The set is > either real or integer; different beasts (although one is a subset of > the other). So you just should be writing "integers." > > Just nits - I'm following your points though. > > > Subtraction closes on the set of real integers, i.e. the difference > > of any two real integers is another real integer. > > A product of two integers is also an integer, but a quotient is not. > > To make division close on our set of numbers, we need to include > > rational fractions. > > Since we can multiply, we can also square ans raise to other powers. > > That leads us to seek roots. (Roots are truly an inverse, because > > there is only one argument.) To arrange that the operation of taking > > a root close, the set of numbers has to be expanded to include > > irrationals, and also (but not so obviously) complex numbers. The > > even-powered root of a negative number requires imaginary numbers. > > Roots of imaginaries reqire complex numbers. So with the inclusion > > of complex numbers, all arithmetic operations close on all entities > > we call numbers. > > Nicely put. I agree, using the terms and notions you've defined. > > > > > > > There are other ways to deal with these difficulties. For example, > > we can avoid the need for negative integers if we create the rule > > that whenever the subtrahend is not smaller than the minuend, we > > reverse the order of the operands and write the difference with red > > ink. (We still need zero.) The overriding advantage of using a > > complete set of numbers and accepting the resuls as they come is > > that there are no conditional operations. > >>> Then _all_ arithmetic operations close. > >> Really? What operations are you referring to? A field only has two > >> operations: addition and multiplication. > > No law of nature requires that we define it that way. Besides, what > > kind of inverse operation has more conditions than the original? > >> � � � � � � � � � � � � � �There is no such operations as > >> subtraction and division. This is the role of *inverses* in > >> algebra. > > I thought I was discussing arithmetic. > >> The reals have all the nice properties you are intimating > >> (translating inverses to the other two operations). So why can't > >> they be the zero of any arbitrary polynomial over the reals? > > I don't know enough to discuss that intelligently. > > Jerry > > Jerry, > > I believe, if I understand you correctly, the umbrella point you're > making through all this is that you can choose to define (and work > with) things in different ways. That I agree 100 percent with. > > However, if you are going another step and maintaining that > the only difference between different respresentations, or > notions, of the various arithmetic systems is the ease of > use (e.g., complex arithmetic makes it easier to write > a product), then I would disagree. > > The method of interpretation we call "abstract algebra" (groups, > rings, fields, integral domains, Euclidean domains, Galois theory, > etc.) is amazingly rich in results, or "fruit." For example: > > � �1. The proof that a polynomial of degree higher than 4 cannot > � �be factored systematically. > > � �2. The fundamental theorem of arithmetic. > > � �3. The overlap of abstract algebra with linear algebra via > � �vector spaces. > > and many others. > > Like a human being, I judge an area of mathematics based on its > fruits, and abstract algebra has been exceedingly fruitful. > > That is not to say that, as relativity superceded Newtonian physics, > there is not something better, so you're right in that this > interpretation isn't necessarily the only "right" one. However, I > contend that the more fruit it bears, the "righter" it is. > -- > Randy Yates � � � � � � � � � � �% "So now it's getting late, > Digital Signal Labs � � � � � � �% � �and those who hesitate > mailto://ya...@ieee.org � � � � �% � �got no one..."http://www.digitalsignallabs.com% 'Waterfall', *Face The Music*, ELO- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text -Hello Randy, There is no question that complex numbers enrich the world of mathematics. The real question (pardon the pun) is do we have to use complex numbers to represent reality? A good physical theory is quantum mechanics (QM) which uses complex numbers at its core. The interesting thing is all measurable things are real valued. And QM certainly goes along this line of thinking. We have the famous quote from the French mathematician Jacques Hadamard: "It has been written that the shortest and best way between two truths of the real domain often passes through the imaginary one." This may be found in various translations from the original French: "On a pu �crire depuis que la voie la plus courte et la meilleure entre deux v�rit�s du domaine r�el passe souvent par le domaine imaginaire." Researchers have not found where this has been written other than by Hadamard himself! Now the question is Do we need to modify Hadamard's statement? I.e., are there some truths in the real domain that must be connected via the complex one? I.e, is the connection one of convenience or necessity? We pretty much accept (at least by physicists) that all measurements are real valued. So buried in this experimental fact is an idea that we don't have to have complex numbers, but Hadamard says that may be much harder to work with. Clay
Reply by ●May 4, 20112011-05-04
On May 4, 10:24�am, Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote:> On May 3, 8:40�pm, Randy Yates <ya...@ieee.org> wrote: > > > Hey Jerry, > > > No, I haven't forgotten about this......> Now the question is Do we need to modify Hadamard's statement? I.e., > are there some truths in the real domain that must be connected via > the complex one? I.e, is the connection one of convenience or > necessity? > > We pretty much accept (at least by physicists) that all measurements > are real valued. So buried in this experimental fact is an idea that > we don't have to have complex numbers, but Hadamard says that may be > much harder to work with.Thank you, Clay for answering Randy for me more comprehensively than I would have done myself. Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get.
Reply by ●May 4, 20112011-05-04
On May 4, 10:45�am, Jerry Avins <j...@ieee.org> wrote:> On May 4, 10:24�am, Clay <c...@claysturner.com> wrote: > > > On May 3, 8:40�pm, Randy Yates <ya...@ieee.org> wrote: > > > > Hey Jerry, > > > > No, I haven't forgotten about this... > > � ... > > > Now the question is Do we need to modify Hadamard's statement? I.e., > > are there some truths in the real domain that must be connected via > > the complex one? I.e, is the connection one of convenience or > > necessity? > > > We pretty much accept (at least by physicists) that all measurements > > are real valued. So buried in this experimental fact is an idea that > > we don't have to have complex numbers, but Hadamard says that may be > > much harder to work with. > > Thank you, Clay for answering Randy for me more comprehensively than I > would have done myself. > > Jerry > -- > Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get.You are welcome. I've also tracked down the original writing that Hadamard himself had referred to. It goes back to Paul Painleve's Analyse des travaux scientifiques (1900) where he says (translated from French) "The natural development of this work soon led the geometers in their studies to embrace imaginary as well as real values of the variable. The theory of Taylor series, that of elliptic functions, the vast field of Cauchy analysis, caused a burst of productivity derived from this generalization. It came to appear that, between two truths of the real domain, the easiest and shortest path quite often passes through the complex domain." So even though Hadamard is often quoted for this, that Painleve wrote it first and Hadamard said it had been written without saying who, so he didn't steal it. Clay







