want to ask plz to publish a paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for exapmle to apply a system that given before for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax and compare between them my question is this such a project can be accepted
accepted by IEEE
Started by ●April 11, 2011
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On Apr 11, 9:28�am, sami <jehan...@yahoo.com> wrote:> want to ask plz > �to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > exapmle to apply a �system �that given before > > for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > �and compare �between them > > my question is this > � such a project can be acceptedI think you do might be doing things in the wrong order. The order of work goes like this: 1) Come up with an idea for a project 2) Get the idea accepted by somebody who can pay you (e.g. get a research scholarship) 3) Do the work 4) Write a paper 5) Submit the paper to e.g. IEEE Only then will IEEE be interested in whatever you are up to. IEEE does not fund projects or accept plans. IEEE does not supervise your work. IEEE only review (and possibly accept to publish) submitted manuscripts that describe work that has already been done. Rune
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On Mon, 11 Apr 2011 00:43:14 -0700 (PDT), Rune Allnor <allnor@tele.ntnu.no> wrote:>On Apr 11, 9:28�am, sami <jehan...@yahoo.com> wrote: >> want to ask plz >> �to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for >> exapmle to apply a �system �that given before >> >> for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax >> >> �and compare �between them >> >> my question is this >> � such a project can be accepted > >I think you do might be doing things in the wrong order. >The order of work goes like this: > >1) Come up with an idea for a project >2) Get the idea accepted by somebody who can pay you > (e.g. get a research scholarship) >3) Do the work >4) Write a paper >5) Submit the paper to e.g. IEEE > >Only then will IEEE be interested in whatever you >are up to. IEEE does not fund projects or accept plans. >IEEE does not supervise your work. > >IEEE only review (and possibly accept to publish) submitted >manuscripts that describe work that has already been done. > >RuneHi Rune, Your ability to interpret truly awful, broken, "English gibberish" is very good. See Ya', [-Rick-]
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On Apr 11, 1:48�pm, Rick Lyons <R.Lyons@_BOGUS_ieee.org> wrote:> On Mon, 11 Apr 2011 00:43:14 -0700 (PDT), Rune Allnor > > > > > > <all...@tele.ntnu.no> wrote: > >On Apr 11, 9:28�am, sami <jehan...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >> want to ask plz > >> �to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > >> exapmle to apply a �system �that given before > > >> for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > >> �and compare �between them > > >> my question is this > >> � such a project can be accepted > > >I think you do might be doing things in the wrong order. > >The order of work goes like this: > > >1) Come up with an idea for a project > >2) Get the idea accepted by somebody who can pay you > > � (e.g. get a research scholarship) > >3) Do the work > >4) Write a paper > >5) Submit the paper to e.g. IEEE > > >Only then will IEEE be interested in whatever you > >are up to. IEEE does not fund projects or accept plans. > >IEEE does not supervise your work. > > >IEEE only review (and possibly accept to publish) submitted > >manuscripts that describe work that has already been done. > > >Rune > > Hi Rune, > � Your ability to interpret truly awful, > broken, "English gibberish" is very good.That's because I've been there - with English when I was a kid and with a couple of other languages in recent years. It's something refreshing about being able to conduct an actual conversation for the first time in some language one has struggeled to get to grips with. Rune
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On Apr 11, 8:26�am, Rune Allnor <all...@tele.ntnu.no> wrote:> On Apr 11, 1:48�pm, Rick Lyons <R.Lyons@_BOGUS_ieee.org> wrote: > > > > > On Mon, 11 Apr 2011 00:43:14 -0700 (PDT), Rune Allnor > > > <all...@tele.ntnu.no> wrote: > > >On Apr 11, 9:28�am, sami <jehan...@yahoo.com> wrote: > > >> want to ask plz > > >> �to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > > >> exapmle to apply a �system �that given before > > > >> for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > > >> �and compare �between them > > > >> my question is this > > >> � such a project can be accepted > > > >I think you do might be doing things in the wrong order. > > >The order of work goes like this: > > > >1) Come up with an idea for a project > > >2) Get the idea accepted by somebody who can pay you > > > � (e.g. get a research scholarship) > > >3) Do the work > > >4) Write a paper > > >5) Submit the paper to e.g. IEEE > > > >Only then will IEEE be interested in whatever you > > >are up to. IEEE does not fund projects or accept plans. > > >IEEE does not supervise your work. > > > >IEEE only review (and possibly accept to publish) submitted > > >manuscripts that describe work that has already been done. > > > >Rune > > > Hi Rune, > > � Your ability to interpret truly awful, > > broken, "English gibberish" is very good. > > That's because I've been there - with English when I was > a kid and with a couple of other languages in recent years. > It's something refreshing about being able to conduct an > actual conversation for the first time in some language > one has struggeled to get to grips with. > > RuneWell Rune, I can guarantee your English is better than my Norwegian :) Cheers, Dave
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On Apr 11, 3:15�pm, Dave <dspg...@netscape.net> wrote:> On Apr 11, 8:26�am, Rune Allnor <all...@tele.ntnu.no> wrote: > > > > > > > On Apr 11, 1:48�pm, Rick Lyons <R.Lyons@_BOGUS_ieee.org> wrote: > > > > On Mon, 11 Apr 2011 00:43:14 -0700 (PDT), Rune Allnor > > > > <all...@tele.ntnu.no> wrote: > > > >On Apr 11, 9:28�am, sami <jehan...@yahoo.com> wrote: > > > >> want to ask plz > > > >> �to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > > > >> exapmle to apply a �system �that given before > > > > >> for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > > > >> �and compare �between them > > > > >> my question is this > > > >> � such a project can be accepted > > > > >I think you do might be doing things in the wrong order. > > > >The order of work goes like this: > > > > >1) Come up with an idea for a project > > > >2) Get the idea accepted by somebody who can pay you > > > > � (e.g. get a research scholarship) > > > >3) Do the work > > > >4) Write a paper > > > >5) Submit the paper to e.g. IEEE > > > > >Only then will IEEE be interested in whatever you > > > >are up to. IEEE does not fund projects or accept plans. > > > >IEEE does not supervise your work. > > > > >IEEE only review (and possibly accept to publish) submitted > > > >manuscripts that describe work that has already been done. > > > > >Rune > > > > Hi Rune, > > > � Your ability to interpret truly awful, > > > broken, "English gibberish" is very good. > > > That's because I've been there - with English when I was > > a kid and with a couple of other languages in recent years. > > It's something refreshing about being able to conduct an > > actual conversation for the first time in some language > > one has struggeled to get to grips with. > > > Rune > > Well Rune, I can guarantee your English is better than my Norwegian :)Some times I wonder if my English is better than my Norwegian... Rune
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
On 4/11/2011 12:28 AM, sami wrote:> want to ask plz > to publish a paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > exapmle to apply a system that given before > > for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > and compare between them > > my question is this > such a project can be acceptedIt depends on the Journal for one thing. The Transactions are generally looking for "original" work. But others not so formal will accept good review articles. I would seek advice from folks who are in the field in which you intend to publish. The reviewers are generally in contact, etc. If you don't "know" the journal to which you submit then it's going to be a long shot. But, if you've been reading it then you'll have a much better idea of what will fly. Or, as above, get the advice of folks who *are* close to the target journal. It's likely you can find them at the local universities. Fred
Reply by ●April 11, 20112011-04-11
>want to ask plz > to publish a paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for >exapmle to apply a system that given before > >for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > and compare between them > >my question is this > such a project can be accepted >Do a good literature survey. It always helps. There is always somebody out there who has work on the idea that you have. If you do not find anything, then go ahead, carry out the work, write a paper and submit to a *GOOD* IEEE conference or a journal. By GOOD I mean, not the conferences that borrow IEEE's name to make money. Hope this helps. Chintan
Reply by ●April 12, 20112011-04-12
On Apr 12, 1:56�pm, "cpshah99" <cpshah99@n_o_s_p_a_m.rediffmail.com> wrote:> >want to ask plz > > to �publish a �paper in IEEE you have to give a new idea or for > >exapmle to apply a �system �that given before > > >for exapmle iam palnning to study diffenet code systems in wimax > > > and compare �between them > > >my question is this > > �such a project can be accepted > > Do a good literature survey. It always helps. There is always somebody out > there who has work on the idea that you have. > > If you do not find anything, then go ahead, carry out the work, write a > paper and submit to a *GOOD* IEEE conference or a journal. > > By GOOD I mean, not the conferences that borrow IEEE's name to make money. > > Hope this helps. > > ChintanAll IEEE sponsored conferences have to be agreed at meetings of the local IEEE chapters. You can't just use the name without permission. Hardy
Reply by ●April 13, 20112011-04-13
On Apr 12, 5:48�pm, HardySpicer <gyansor...@gmail.com> wrote:> On Apr 12, 1:56�pm, "cpshah99" <cpshah99@n_o_s_p_a_m.rediffmail.com>> > If you do not find anything, then go ahead, carry out the work, write a > > paper and submit to a *GOOD* IEEE conference or a journal. > > > By GOOD I mean, not the conferences that borrow IEEE's name to make money. > > > Hope this helps. > > > Chintan > > All IEEE sponsored conferences have to be agreed at meetings of the > local IEEE chapters. > You can't just use the name without permission.That might be true, but I interpret Chintan's remark to mean that a conference might not be 'good' even if it has obtained the permissions and support of the IEEE. Rune
