DSPRelated.com
Forums
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →

Solar Roadways

Started by Randy Yates ●June 17, 2014
On 6/19/2014 1:17 PM, robert bristow-johnson wrote:
> On 6/19/14 4:32 AM, rickman wrote: > >> Besides, this may sound like a "great" idea, but I didn't see any >> mention of cost. > > pretty big, but i wouldn't hold that against the idea. sometimes > infrastructure that ultimately saves a lotta resources costs a helluva > lot to start with. and sometimes it really grows on you. consider > Boston's Big Dig, for example. if they had said in 1982 that this thing > would cost $22B and 25 years, they could never get voter and political > approval. but, once committed, they had to carry it through and, i > think, ultimately it is to the common good. > > that doesn't mean though that the country is ready for solar freakin' > roadways yet.
Until some one comes up with *real* numbers showing it to be even remotely practical I see no point in pursuing it. The current research is aimed at demonstrating some of the technical aspects of the matter. But that is irrelevant until someone can show the big picture. We don't need to solve any of the problems with driving on them until you can show how the overall system works. Too much focus on the small picture and none on the big picture. In other words, why fight the battle when you can't win the war?
>> How can it be profitable to put solar cells underneath >> all the cars in parking lots? > > in my opinion, ground settling that causes potholes really precludes > putting this under cars at the parking lots. it would be cheaper and > shadier and more accessible for maintenance to put a little slanted and > flat roof over those parking lots with the solar arrays mounted flat > against that roof. same 1200 watts per meter^2 of sunlight and you > don't have to dig up the whole damn place to repair some broken or > shorted electrical connection.
You completely miss the point. Putting the solar cells in the parking lot pavement is *not* the same 1200 Watts per sq meter. It would be *maybe* half that from all the shade from the cars. Putting the solar cells anywhere other than on *top* of other things makes no sense at all.
> my daughter showed me that Solar Freakin' Roadways video before i saw > Randy post it. it's sorta like the HUVr hype (look that one up and have > a giggle). she couldn't figger out why i was so skeptical of both. > > SOLAR FREAKIN' ROADWAYS WITH ANTI-GRAVITY HOVERBOARDS AND MY LITTLE PONY > TO BOOT!!!!! > > a wonderful future awaits us.
Not me, I'm too much the curmudgeon. -- Rick
On 6/19/2014 2:09 PM, Randy Yates wrote:
> rickman <gnuarm@gmail.com> writes: > >> On 6/19/2014 10:09 AM, Randy Yates wrote: >>> Tim Wescott <tim@seemywebsite.really> writes: >>> >>>> On Tue, 17 Jun 2014 14:33:22 -0400, Randy Yates wrote: >>>> >>>>> This looks really good. They are moving forward. >>>>> >>>>> http://www.solarroadways.com >>>>> >>>>> Hey IEEE, why haven't you done a few articles on this? This blows the >>>>> whole, feeble green energy/smart grid/blah-blah-blah marketing crap into >>>>> the dust. >>>> >>>> I think it's a nifty idea on the surface, but I don't think that it's >>>> going to take the pounding that a well-traveled urban road has to take. >>>> I think the idea will remain cool and sexy right up until they put a test >>>> section on a slice of I-anything and try to keep it running for a >>>> year. >>> >>> Tim, >>> >>> That is what I thought right off. And it is true that I don't know how >>> much (if any) real-world testing they've done yet. >>> >>> But as I read between the lines and gathered more information, I think >>> this is real. They have consulted with some experienced and educated >>> individuals who specialize in materials, mechanical and civil >>> engineering, etc. >>> >>> Are we better at judging such things than they? >>> >>> http://www.solarroadways.com/board.shtml >> >> Wow. So you acknowledge that the facts point to this thing not being >> workable > > Where did I acknowledge any such thing? > >> and instead you prefer to put your faith in the judgement of >> others, those who should know better than you? > > Unlike you (apparently), I do not believe I know everything.
You seem to think you know about this issue. I am only looking at the facts, not the hype. I don't see how anyone with any technical ability can't see how poor an idea this is. Eric put it well when he points out that the two different applications, roads and photovoltaic energy collection have little common ground to exploit. In fact the *only* common ground is that... the common ground. Both use real estate. Everything else about them conflicts and reduces the effectiveness of each in a poor tradeoff. As Eric also points out, there is no shortage of space to place solar collectors. So this thing is a poor solution to a problem that doesn't exist. Is that really not obvious? -- Rick
rickman <gnuarm@gmail.com> writes:

> On 6/19/2014 2:09 PM, Randy Yates wrote: >> rickman <gnuarm@gmail.com> writes: >> >>> On 6/19/2014 10:09 AM, Randy Yates wrote: >>>> Tim Wescott <tim@seemywebsite.really> writes: >>>> >>>>> On Tue, 17 Jun 2014 14:33:22 -0400, Randy Yates wrote: >>>>> >>>>>> This looks really good. They are moving forward. >>>>>> >>>>>> http://www.solarroadways.com >>>>>> >>>>>> Hey IEEE, why haven't you done a few articles on this? This blows the >>>>>> whole, feeble green energy/smart grid/blah-blah-blah marketing crap into >>>>>> the dust. >>>>> >>>>> I think it's a nifty idea on the surface, but I don't think that it's >>>>> going to take the pounding that a well-traveled urban road has to take. >>>>> I think the idea will remain cool and sexy right up until they put a test >>>>> section on a slice of I-anything and try to keep it running for a >>>>> year. >>>> >>>> Tim, >>>> >>>> That is what I thought right off. And it is true that I don't know how >>>> much (if any) real-world testing they've done yet. >>>> >>>> But as I read between the lines and gathered more information, I think >>>> this is real. They have consulted with some experienced and educated >>>> individuals who specialize in materials, mechanical and civil >>>> engineering, etc. >>>> >>>> Are we better at judging such things than they? >>>> >>>> http://www.solarroadways.com/board.shtml >>> >>> Wow. So you acknowledge that the facts point to this thing not being >>> workable >> >> Where did I acknowledge any such thing? >> >>> and instead you prefer to put your faith in the judgement of >>> others, those who should know better than you? >> >> Unlike you (apparently), I do not believe I know everything. > > You seem to think you know about this issue. I am only looking at the > facts, not the hype. > > I don't see how anyone with any technical ability can't see how poor > an idea this is. Eric put it well when he points out that the two > different applications, roads and photovoltaic energy collection have > little common ground to exploit. In fact the *only* common ground is > that... the common ground. Both use real estate. Everything else > about them conflicts and reduces the effectiveness of each in a poor > tradeoff. As Eric also points out, there is no shortage of space to > place solar collectors. So this thing is a poor solution to a problem > that doesn't exist. > > Is that really not obvious?
It is not to me, but you may be right. I am content to see if the idea is proven out or not. -- Randy Yates Digital Signal Labs http://www.digitalsignallabs.com
eric.jacobsen@ieee.org (Eric Jacobsen) writes:
> [...] > Roads need tough, sticky surfaces that provide good traction in all > weather conditions and can stand shock, vibration, impact, chemicals, > and serious abrasion from vehicular use.
If a surface provides good traction, why does it need to be "sticky?" With this exception, I agree. How do you know these do not fit the bill? As they stated on the video, this isn't your typical bathroom mirror glass. Glass can be made about as strong as steel.
> The road surface needs to be crowned for drainage and often banked, > without regard for what direction the sunlight is coming from. Using > such a surface for energy collection seems daft, as it is not an > efficient surface for doing so.
I believe they have thought that through thoroughly. See the video about the side trenches that collect and transport drainage.
> Tilting solar collectors toward the sun, even a little bit, provides a > significant increase in their efficiency. Putting them in a road > precludes that, as the road needs to be tilted for the vehicular use, > which will often be counterproductive for energy collection. > Likewise roads are often shaded, and lots of vehicular use shades them > even more. Basically, if it is a successful road, it will suck as a > solar energy collector. > > So, yeah, it just smells in general. The hype is great for raising > money, though.
Neither good nor bad ideas require our agreement. We shall see if the concept is proven out or not. -- Randy Yates Digital Signal Labs http://www.digitalsignallabs.com
eric.jacobsen@ieee.org (Eric Jacobsen) writes:
> [...] > Tilting solar collectors toward the sun, even a little bit, provides a > significant increase in their efficiency. Putting them in a road > precludes that, as the road needs to be tilted for the vehicular use, > which will often be counterproductive for energy collection. > Likewise roads are often shaded, and lots of vehicular use shades them > even more. Basically, if it is a successful road, it will suck as a > solar energy collector.
Except for the shading by vehicles, they address this here: http://solarroadways.com/numbers.shtml I was disappointed to see that they did not account for shading by vehicles on the road. Basically it seems that any inefficiency due to tilting is more than made up for by the quantity of roads available. Of course that would have to factor into the costs. It was interesting to see their observation that flat solar panel collection is actually higher than angled on cloudy days. I'd like to make a comment to everyone: Just like a complex electrical or communication system design, the devil is in the details. It appears to me, even at my relatively shallow level of analysis, that there are many, many interrelated factors involved in this concept. That fact could work either for or against its success. I agree that more testing is necessary. -- Randy Yates Digital Signal Labs http://www.digitalsignallabs.com
On 6/19/14 3:51 PM, rickman wrote:
> On 6/19/2014 1:17 PM, robert bristow-johnson wrote: >> On 6/19/14 4:32 AM, rickman wrote: >> >>> Besides, this may sound like a "great" idea, but I didn't see any >>> mention of cost. >> >> pretty big, but i wouldn't hold that against the idea. sometimes >> infrastructure that ultimately saves a lotta resources costs a helluva >> lot to start with. and sometimes it really grows on you. consider >> Boston's Big Dig, for example. if they had said in 1982 that this thing >> would cost $22B and 25 years, they could never get voter and political >> approval. but, once committed, they had to carry it through and, i >> think, ultimately it is to the common good. >> >> that doesn't mean though that the country is ready for solar freakin' >> roadways yet. > > Until some one comes up with *real* numbers showing it to be even > remotely practical I see no point in pursuing it. The current research > is aimed at demonstrating some of the technical aspects of the matter. > But that is irrelevant until someone can show the big picture. We don't > need to solve any of the problems with driving on them until you can > show how the overall system works.
i imagine the idea is that these solar cells, however efficient they may be, will put a lotta juice into the grid if widely adopted. then, i guess if there are batteries distributed around with the solar cells, since there is more juice, nationwide, than we need, you can spend a lot of it lighting up the road in a futuristic and programmable manner. so you're driving at 3 a.m. and nod off and start to drift over to the rumble strips and the whole Solar Friggin' Roadway lights up hot pink telling you to wake the hell up. maybe it's a way for the driver to watch television displayed on the road in front of his/her car. wouldn't that be cool? watch TV without taking your eyes offa the road!
> > Too much focus on the small picture and none on the big picture. In > other words, why fight the battle when you can't win the war? >
this isn't war. it's the wunnerful future we're promised along with the HUVr boards (did you see that, rick?) and PicturePhones and 2-way wrist TV (as in Dick Tracy). with them HUVr boards, the same technology can be used to lift passengers and cargo into space. imagine really cool moon outposts where people go to visit for a few months and research, sorta like at the South Pole today. "warp speed" and "replicators" and "teleporters" (even before Star Trek, i thought it would be cool if you could pass a sandwich or something through the phone to the other party) is just around the corner a few hundred years. at the rate of technical advancement, it's inevitable. or, if you don't believe that, there's Ray Kurzwiel's vision that reasonably soon we'll be building silicon-based prostheses that go into our brains and enhance it. just imagine having a built-in 80-bit floating-point coprocessor installed in our heads and we could access it by thought and little menu shades would drop down in our perceived field of vision like it did for the Terminator. so we get to do Spock-like or Data-like calculations in our brains without the need for pencil and paper. fast and effortless. but if there was a failure, like the Pentium FDIV bug, we wouldn't know it (except i'll bet some aspie kid with the implant would notice). so beside's utility co-processors, we also have memory added to head off problems of memory loss that Alzheimer's people get, and more co-processors to aid other cognitive functions. more and more of our cognitive functions go into the prostheses as they get more and more developed and capable. then some of our consciousness moves into the silicon and someday *all* of it (maybe we could leave behind a few of our schizy personalities behind or some of them nagging inside voices) or as much as we could tell. then, some technician pops out the tera-quad FPGA where we now reside, plug it into the Matrix (toss the decrepit carbon-based empty hulk into a dumpster or have a green burial or make soylent-green outa it), and we'll have a joyous eternity in the FPGA (connected to other FPGAs in a helluva network) until there's a power failure for the server room. or maybe plug it into a robot or android that lives as long as Data does (i wanna be a robot with wheels). i don't think that diverts too far from Kurzwiel's vision. he seems to be a quite successful (financially in his current incarnation) futurist. it's gotta be plausible. hey, ya never know. (like the NY Lotto ads.) :-\
> >>> How can it be profitable to put solar cells underneath >>> all the cars in parking lots? >> >> in my opinion, ground settling that causes potholes really precludes >> putting this under cars at the parking lots. it would be cheaper and >> shadier and more accessible for maintenance to put a little slanted and >> flat roof over those parking lots with the solar arrays mounted flat >> against that roof. same 1200 watts per meter^2 of sunlight and you >> don't have to dig up the whole damn place to repair some broken or >> shorted electrical connection. > > You completely miss the point. Putting the solar cells in the parking > lot pavement is *not* the same 1200 Watts per sq meter. It would be > *maybe* half that from all the shade from the cars. Putting the solar > cells anywhere other than on *top* of other things makes no sense at all. >
i *thought* i was sorta making the same point. making it shadier for the "other things" means the same as "on *top*". if, suppose it *were* practical to build, say I-94 in North Dakota outa these things, being covered by the occasional car whizzing by doesn't seem to be much of a problem. being under that (if, for all other reasons, it were feasible) is not on the face of it nonsensical, but you don't have to look very far (into the all other reasons) to run into transparent problems.
> >> my daughter showed me that Solar Freakin' Roadways video before i saw >> Randy post it. it's sorta like the HUVr hype (look that one up and have >> a giggle).
no, really do look up the HUVr thing. it's amazing. Moby is plugging it. and some other celebs. it's gotta be real.
> she couldn't figger out why i was so skeptical of both. >> >> SOLAR FREAKIN' ROADWAYS WITH ANTI-GRAVITY HOVERBOARDS AND MY LITTLE PONY >> TO BOOT!!!!! >> >> a wonderful future awaits us. > > Not me, I'm too much the curmudgeon. >
well, i'm the cynic. -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."
On 6/19/14 12:32 PM, Tim Wescott wrote:
> On Thu, 19 Jun 2014 05:08:01 -0400, rickman wrote: >> >> An award winning silly idea. > > If it brings in money... >
you mean investment money. like Zeosync? remember that from around the turn of the century? this link still works: http://news.cnet.com/The-quest-for-near-perfect-compression/2100-1023_3-839851.html Shannon be damned. ("no, i didn't mean it, Claude!") -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."
On 6/19/14 3:06 PM, Eric Jacobsen wrote:
>
...
> > Solar collectors like to be up high where they're never subject to > shade, and when you do that they can have the added benefit of > providing shade. Roads are the opposite. > > Roads need tough, sticky surfaces that provide good traction in all > weather conditions and can stand shock, vibration, impact, chemicals, > and serious abrasion from vehicular use.
SOLAR FRICKIN" ROADWAYS, goddammit! :-o don't be so damn negative, Eric. self-fulfilling prophecy. -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."
On 6/19/14 3:46 PM, glen herrmannsfeldt wrote:
...
> > I missed the beginning, so maybe I have the wrong idea. It does > seem to me that roads would make poor photovoltaic power systems, > but I haven't thought through solar thermal. > > The usual design of a solar thermal plant has many mirrors focussing > sunlight to a small enough spot, generate high temperature steam > and run a steam turbine from that. Keeping the mirrors clean and > pointing the right direction isn't easy. A higher temperature > increases the Carnot efficiency, and you need a good source of > cooling water for the thermal sink. > > Now, consider roads as solar thermal collectors. You would want pipes > through them to warm up water. It wouldn't get all that warm, but > the cost of the pipes is much less than big mirrors. The Carnot > efficiency will be very low, but maybe that isn't a problem. > > Even more, cooling the road surface is probably good. Warm road > surfaces get soft, not good for traction. The collection might be > done with fairly cheap plastic pipe.
and water pumped through pipes in the road won't be a problem anywhere we get potholes or any significant ground sinking. can't imagine any problem with that. -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."
On 6/19/14 6:49 PM, Randy Yates wrote:
> eric.jacobsen@ieee.org (Eric Jacobsen) writes: >> [...] >> Tilting solar collectors toward the sun, even a little bit, provides a >> significant increase in their efficiency. Putting them in a road >> precludes that, as the road needs to be tilted for the vehicular use, >> which will often be counterproductive for energy collection. >> Likewise roads are often shaded, and lots of vehicular use shades them >> even more. Basically, if it is a successful road, it will suck as a >> solar energy collector. > > Except for the shading by vehicles, they address this here: > > http://solarroadways.com/numbers.shtml > > I was disappointed to see that they did not account for shading by > vehicles on the road.
to me, Randy, that's the least of the problems. at least for roadways out in the middle of nowhere (like between Dickinson and Mandan North Dakota). if, for some reason it was otherwise feasible, the occasional car or semi-truck whizzing by would not be a big deal.) i dunno. it's just that i gotta kick out of the Solar Fuckin' Roadways video as well as the HUVr video when my kid showed them to me. dunno how i'm gonna disabuse her of the astrology notion either. -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."