Hi Anand, On 8/12/2014 9:32 PM, Anand P. Paralkar wrote:> I see most of the people who respond to questions are practicing----------------------------------------------------^^^ or, "were". Don't discount retirees, etc.> experts. Their job/consultancy/business is in the domain of the forum > where we post questions. > > (Without being rude and with no other intention) How do you people have > the time?For folks in their own business, you have control over your own time. No PHB to "force" a 9-5 on you. E.g., I can work as little or as much as I want on any given day, EVERY day. I'm answerable to myself only. In the US, I've seen figures claiming as much as 2 hrs per day is "wasted" at the typical job -- answering email, surfing the web, chatting on the phone, chatting by the water cooler, etc. (all "personal" tasks unrelated to work) [I know this seems excessive! But, every time I've looked into it, the figure remains uncontested! :< ] For that hypothetical worker, this represents "distraction time"; their desire to escape what they SHOULD be doing. How does that differ from an engineer wanting to distract himself with something engineering-related... yet NOT (necessarily) germane to his "current workload"?> My guesses are as follows: > > a. The experts are so damn expert that what takes me an hour could take > a minute for the expert. Thus, they are able to "serve" and they can do > so in about fraction of the time.Or, they may have already *done* what you are asking -- or, something close enough that they can easily offer guidance/opinion.> b. The experts are in between two consultancy contracts and they don't > mind tickling their fancy with newbie questions.Even on "down" time, you're not sitting around twiddling your thumbs! Preparing proposals, maintaining/purchasing equipment/software, "cleaning up" after previous project(s), investigating other fields of interest/technologies, etc. But, again, your time is your own. Perhaps reading/posting something here helps you prepare that proposal. Or, gives you an idea as to a new tool/equipment investment. Or, allows you to peek into other folks' past experiences to glean a bit of info about a new technology that you want to explore, etc.> c. Some of them are in semi-retirement. (No, no, no, I don't want to be > rude.)Or *real* retirement! :> But, that doesn't mean they can't still be spending as many weekly hours applying their skills to other projects -- for pay, investment or otherwise! One thing I've been surprised to learn (though find it "obvious" in hindsight!) is how long it takes to disengage yourself from your "formal" career as you retire from a consultancy. For a 9-to-5, you just *retire* -- on a particular day and at a particular time. The "business" persists without you. The *business* has obligations to its customers, shareholders, etc. -- those obligations don't translate to being *your* obligations! Not so in a consultancy, etc. Its a lot harder to "disentangle" yourself from clients and customers that have been *your* clients and customers -- without feeling like you are leaving them with a "problem" (finding a replacement for your services). The 9-to-5 scenario skips over that! "It's not my problem..."
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
On Good Questions
Started by ●August 9, 2014
Reply by ●August 13, 20142014-08-13
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On Wed, 13 Aug 2014 11:07:44 -0700, Don Y <this@is.not.me.com> wrote:>Hi Anand, > >On 8/12/2014 9:32 PM, Anand P. Paralkar wrote: > >> I see most of the people who respond to questions are practicing >----------------------------------------------------^^^ or, "were". >Don't discount retirees, etc. >> experts. Their job/consultancy/business is in the domain of the forum >> where we post questions. >> >> (Without being rude and with no other intention) How do you people have >> the time? > >For folks in their own business, you have control over your own time. >No PHB to "force" a 9-5 on you. E.g., I can work as little or as >much as I want on any given day, EVERY day. I'm answerable to myself >only. > >In the US, I've seen figures claiming as much as 2 hrs per day is >"wasted" at the typical job -- answering email, surfing the web, >chatting on the phone, chatting by the water cooler, etc. (all >"personal" tasks unrelated to work) > >[I know this seems excessive! But, every time I've looked into it, >the figure remains uncontested! :< ]IME it is growing to an even higher percentage.> >For that hypothetical worker, this represents "distraction time"; >their desire to escape what they SHOULD be doing. How does that >differ from an engineer wanting to distract himself with something >engineering-related... yet NOT (necessarily) germane to his "current >workload"? > >> My guesses are as follows: >> >> a. The experts are so damn expert that what takes me an hour could take >> a minute for the expert. Thus, they are able to "serve" and they can do >> so in about fraction of the time. > >Or, they may have already *done* what you are asking -- or, something >close enough that they can easily offer guidance/opinion. > >> b. The experts are in between two consultancy contracts and they don't >> mind tickling their fancy with newbie questions. > >Even on "down" time, you're not sitting around twiddling your thumbs! >Preparing proposals, maintaining/purchasing equipment/software, >"cleaning up" after previous project(s), investigating other fields >of interest/technologies, etc. > >But, again, your time is your own. Perhaps reading/posting something >here helps you prepare that proposal. Or, gives you an idea as to >a new tool/equipment investment. Or, allows you to peek into other >folks' past experiences to glean a bit of info about a new technology >that you want to explore, etc.That is part of why i am here.> >> c. Some of them are in semi-retirement. (No, no, no, I don't want to be >> rude.) > >Or *real* retirement! :> But, that doesn't mean they can't still >be spending as many weekly hours applying their skills to other >projects -- for pay, investment or otherwise! > >One thing I've been surprised to learn (though find it "obvious" in >hindsight!) is how long it takes to disengage yourself from your >"formal" career as you retire from a consultancy. For a 9-to-5, >you just *retire* -- on a particular day and at a particular time. >The "business" persists without you. The *business* has obligations >to its customers, shareholders, etc. -- those obligations don't >translate to being *your* obligations! > >Not so in a consultancy, etc. Its a lot harder to "disentangle" >yourself from clients and customers that have been *your* clients >and customers -- without feeling like you are leaving them with a >"problem" (finding a replacement for your services). The 9-to-5 >scenario skips over that! "It's not my problem..."In my current job i am an internal consultant (a subject matter expert) for a lot of the electronic things done at my current employer. This gives me an obvious path to exploit when i retire and go consulting instead. ?-)
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
Hi Joseph, On 8/13/2014 8:36 PM, josephkk wrote: [attrs elided]>>> b. The experts are in between two consultancy contracts and they don't >>> mind tickling their fancy with newbie questions. >> >> Even on "down" time, you're not sitting around twiddling your thumbs! >> Preparing proposals, maintaining/purchasing equipment/software, >> "cleaning up" after previous project(s), investigating other fields >> of interest/technologies, etc. >> >> But, again, your time is your own. Perhaps reading/posting something >> here helps you prepare that proposal. Or, gives you an idea as to >> a new tool/equipment investment. Or, allows you to peek into other >> folks' past experiences to glean a bit of info about a new technology >> that you want to explore, etc. > > That is part of why i am here.I think for folks with narrow application domains or "niche" skillsets, there isn't as much appeal, here. Chances are, they may already know a good deal of what needs to be known in that narrow field. OTOH, if you (like me) are "all over the place" withthe variety of problems you are called on to (or interested in!) address, then the variety, here, is an asset. Particularly if you are good at abstract thought -- being able to *imagine* how a particular technology can be exploited in a different manner to address a problem in which you have an interest. (sadly, many people seem incapable of this level of abstract thought: "Why do you want to do that?" being their response to your queries)>>> c. Some of them are in semi-retirement. (No, no, no, I don't want to be >>> rude.) >> >> Or *real* retirement! :> But, that doesn't mean they can't still >> be spending as many weekly hours applying their skills to other >> projects -- for pay, investment or otherwise! >> >> One thing I've been surprised to learn (though find it "obvious" in >> hindsight!) is how long it takes to disengage yourself from your >> "formal" career as you retire from a consultancy. For a 9-to-5, >> you just *retire* -- on a particular day and at a particular time. >> The "business" persists without you. The *business* has obligations >> to its customers, shareholders, etc. -- those obligations don't >> translate to being *your* obligations! >> >> Not so in a consultancy, etc. Its a lot harder to "disentangle" >> yourself from clients and customers that have been *your* clients >> and customers -- without feeling like you are leaving them with a >> "problem" (finding a replacement for your services). The 9-to-5 >> scenario skips over that! "It's not my problem..." > > In my current job i am an internal consultant (a subject matter expert) > for a lot of the electronic things done at my current employer. This > gives me an obvious path to exploit when i retire and go consulting > instead.For me, retirement is choosing my *own* projects/problems to solve; not waiting for someone to be willing to pay me to solve one of *theirs* (in which I may/maynot have an interest). I.e., taking the skills others have *paid* me to learn/refine and appying those to problems that *I* find interesting!
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On 14/08/14 04:47, Don Y wrote:> I think for folks with narrow application domains or "niche" skillsets, > there isn't as much appeal, here. Chances are, they may already know > a good deal of what needs to be known in that narrow field. > > OTOH, if you (like me) are "all over the place" withthe variety of > problems you are called on to (or interested in!) address, then the > variety, here, is an asset. Particularly if you are good at abstract > thought -- being able to *imagine* how a particular technology can > be exploited in a different manner to address a problem in which you > have an interest. (sadly, many people seem incapable of this level > of abstract thought: "Why do you want to do that?" being their > response to your queries):), or should I mean ":("> For me, retirement is choosing my *own* projects/problems to solve; > not waiting for someone to be willing to pay me to solve one of > *theirs* (in which I may/maynot have an interest). I.e., taking > the skills others have *paid* me to learn/refine and appying those > to problems that *I* find interesting!Yes too true, but I hadn't thought of it in those terms. I'll remember that!
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On 8/9/14 3:39 PM, Tim Wescott wrote:>...> We're working for you, but we're not working for money. We're working > for satisfaction -- even coming back on and saying "thanks for your > effort, guys, I found the answer somewhere else" will give us more > satisfaction than not saying anything.Tim, i will peak at some of the responses, but i don't have time to read all 50 or so. so someone else may have already pointed this out (lemme know): sometimes, getting the question formed into a "Good question", is nearly sufficient to get the OP to answer the question. the answer becomes evident. that's sometimes where it is legit to ask poorly-formed questions and get help by straightening out the question into a well-formed question that them "experts" (whoever they are) will have enough to know when each unanswered element of the question is actually answered. i've found use in reading (usually regarding communications engineering, which i am not really involved in) responses to not-well-defined questions that forced the OP to refine the question to a state where it actually means something tangible and specific. so, even though these OPs don't make our life easy by asking such questions, sometimes others just as dumb as the OP (like me) can learn something seeing these specific elements emerge in the nascent "good question". i'm gonna select some answers (Eric et.al.) and if i miss a good subthread of this thread, someone lemme know please. -- r b-j rbj@audioimagination.com "Imagination is more important than knowledge."
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
Hi Tom, On 8/14/2014 8:06 AM, Tom Gardner wrote:> On 14/08/14 04:47, Don Y wrote:>> For me, retirement is choosing my *own* projects/problems to solve; >> not waiting for someone to be willing to pay me to solve one of >> *theirs* (in which I may/maynot have an interest). I.e., taking >> the skills others have *paid* me to learn/refine and appying those >> to problems that *I* find interesting! > > Yes too true, but I hadn't thought of it in those terms. > I'll remember that!I honestly can't understand a mindset that sticks to one skillset, application domain, etc. for an entire career. To me, it would be like "digging ditches" -- regardless of the pay level and/or proficiency attained, it's just "the same thing, over and over" ("Oooo! The soil here has a high concentration of loam -- instead of clay!" <shrug>) How many power supplies do you design before you say, "Um, I'm pretty sure I've got this skill 'down'..." and ache to move onto something new? How many different sort() routines? User interfaces? Math packages, etc.? Similarly, there's a point at which it gets harder and harder to find folks who are willing to pay you to learn something "new" (to you). At that point, it's inevitable that you become a "ditch-digger" (though you now have a larger variety of "ditches" to choose between). So, if you want continued variety and challenge, you have to resort to your own imagination: "Gee, wouldn't it be great if...". Of course, deciding when you can "afford" to do that is a matter of personal comfort: how well you've saved/invested, how comfortable you are in your assessment of your own future need$, life expectancy, number and types of folks who "depend" on you and the extent of your commitment to them, physical/mental condition and prognosis, etc. On the flip side, how much capacity to undertake new ideas and concepts do you expect to have as you get older? Given that you don't *already* have something under your belt, are you confident that you'll have the mental and physical skills to "pick it up" when you're 60? 65? 70? What recourse will you have if the above proves NOT to be the case? (blindness, tremor, stroke, fatigue, respiratory problems, memory, hearing, dexterity, strength, etc.) [Dunno about you, but I find the things that I want to learn get more taxing -- perhaps because they *are* more complex! -- to pick up as I get older! E.g., the idea of learning another foreign language at my age would be far too frustrating! It's a challenge for me just to resolve the subtle differences among the sounds of English speech in order to understand fine differences in pronunciation rules at my current "state of decay"^H^H^H age! :> ] (sigh) Off to deliver some goodies...
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On 14/08/14 18:28, Don Y wrote:> I honestly can't understand a mindset that sticks to one skillset, > application domain, etc. for an entire career. To me, it would be > like "digging ditches" -- regardless of the pay level and/or proficiency > attained, it's just "the same thing, over and over" ("Oooo! The soil > here has a high concentration of loam -- instead of clay!" <shrug>)Counterexample, probably apocryphal, but who cares... A newly minted maths graduate got a job assembling vacuum cleaners. After a few months they realised he was capable of more, and repeatedly gently tried to get him to move into management etc. Eventually they asked him why not. He replied that he deliberately got a job that he could learn in 30mins and thereafter do mindlessly. Why? Because while he was ostensibly assembling vacuum cleaners, actually he was indulging in his passion: playing games of chess. I've always admired someone that can work out what's /really/ important to them, and then find a way to achieve it.
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
Hi Tom, On 8/14/2014 10:36 AM, Tom Gardner wrote:> On 14/08/14 18:28, Don Y wrote: >> I honestly can't understand a mindset that sticks to one skillset, >> application domain, etc. for an entire career. To me, it would be >> like "digging ditches" -- regardless of the pay level and/or proficiency >> attained, it's just "the same thing, over and over" ("Oooo! The soil >> here has a high concentration of loam -- instead of clay!" <shrug>) > > Counterexample, probably apocryphal, but who cares... > > A newly minted maths graduate got a job assembling > vacuum cleaners. After a few months they realised he > was capable of more, and repeatedly gently tried to > get him to move into management etc. Eventually they > asked him why not. > > He replied that he deliberately got a job that he > could learn in 30mins and thereafter do mindlessly. > Why? Because while he was ostensibly assembling > vacuum cleaners, actually he was indulging in his > passion: playing games of chess. > > I've always admired someone that can work out what's > /really/ important to them, and then find a way to > achieve it.Exactly! I'm not advocating folks follow *my* approach to life, career, etc. Rather, indicating what I, early on, realized was "really important to me" and how I went about getting that out of my life, career, etc. E.g., I have stubbornly resisted management roles beyond "project management". And, even there, have limited my "touch" to ensuring everyone on the team has what they need to do their job (*my* view of a manager's true role!) instead of "playing policeman". I've a friend who was essentially "set for life" in his 20's. He's moved on -- but to more expensive versions of what he was doing "back then". From my perspective, a "waste of talent" -- as he was immensely capable of doing anything he set his mind to! *But*, he is apparently happy (and very $ucce$$ful!) doing it. [*I* would rather trade potential $$ for the ability to reclaim *my* time on the planet] So, what "works" for one may not for another.
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On Thu, 14 Aug 2014 18:36:47 +0100, Tom Gardner wrote:> On 14/08/14 18:28, Don Y wrote: >> I honestly can't understand a mindset that sticks to one skillset, >> application domain, etc. for an entire career. To me, it would be like >> "digging ditches" -- regardless of the pay level and/or proficiency >> attained, it's just "the same thing, over and over" ("Oooo! The soil >> here has a high concentration of loam -- instead of clay!" <shrug>) > > Counterexample, probably apocryphal, but who cares... > > A newly minted maths graduate got a job assembling vacuum cleaners. > After a few months they realised he was capable of more, and repeatedly > gently tried to get him to move into management etc. Eventually they > asked him why not. > > He replied that he deliberately got a job that he could learn in 30mins > and thereafter do mindlessly. Why? Because while he was ostensibly > assembling vacuum cleaners, actually he was indulging in his passion: > playing games of chess. > > I've always admired someone that can work out what's /really/ important > to them, and then find a way to achieve it.Well, yes. I had a coworker once who's professed ambition was to recharge his unemployment and then start gently pissing off the boss until he was laid off (the boss never fired anyone -- he laid them off, and then hired a replacement. Anyone who's employed people knows how kosher that is). Then when his unemployment ran out, he'd apply for work again. -- Tim Wescott Wescott Design Services http://www.wescottdesign.com
Reply by ●August 14, 20142014-08-14
On Thu, 14 Aug 2014 12:59:15 -0500, Tim Wescott <seemywebsite@myfooter.really> wrote:>On Thu, 14 Aug 2014 18:36:47 +0100, Tom Gardner wrote: > >> On 14/08/14 18:28, Don Y wrote: >>> I honestly can't understand a mindset that sticks to one skillset, >>> application domain, etc. for an entire career. To me, it would be like >>> "digging ditches" -- regardless of the pay level and/or proficiency >>> attained, it's just "the same thing, over and over" ("Oooo! The soil >>> here has a high concentration of loam -- instead of clay!" <shrug>) >> >> Counterexample, probably apocryphal, but who cares... >> >> A newly minted maths graduate got a job assembling vacuum cleaners. >> After a few months they realised he was capable of more, and repeatedly >> gently tried to get him to move into management etc. Eventually they >> asked him why not. >> >> He replied that he deliberately got a job that he could learn in 30mins >> and thereafter do mindlessly. Why? Because while he was ostensibly >> assembling vacuum cleaners, actually he was indulging in his passion: >> playing games of chess. >> >> I've always admired someone that can work out what's /really/ important >> to them, and then find a way to achieve it. > >Well, yes. I had a coworker once who's professed ambition was to recharge >his unemployment and then start gently pissing off the boss until he was >laid off (the boss never fired anyone -- he laid them off, and then hired >a replacement. Anyone who's employed people knows how kosher that is). >Then when his unemployment ran out, he'd apply for work again.Yeah, I hired a guy like that once. He gradually damaged more and more expensive equipment and tools until he was laid off. Serially unemployed. --sp







