Rune Allnor wrote:> > Jerry Avins wrote: > > >>The seeing here is so poor what with smog and urban lights, that I >>haven't been able to see much for a few years. I brought my 80 mm to >>Berkeley, CA, expecting to spend a few days at Inverness on Point Reyes, >>but that didn't happen and it rained (out of season; everything is out >>of season including hurricanes) most of the time. For all the good the >>C5 does me, you might as well have it. > > > Well, I bought my telescope because I always have been very interested > in astronomy. The problem is that in my neck of the woods, there would > be like 60 clear nights per year, 40 of them in the summer season where > > there are but one star (the sun) to be seen. Buying an astro telescope > that potentially can be used 10 - 20 nights per year, just doesn't make > > sense. > > So instead of buying a specialist tool to be used once in a blue moon, > I bought a spotting scope that could double (at least to some extent) > as a astronomy scope. The spotting scope works reasonably well for the > moon and the major planets, but that's about it. Perhaps it's the > seeing > that is to poor, or I just don't want to mess around with no finder > scope and standard tripod mount. Whatever the reason for not doing > astronomy, I discovered birding, which seems to have been a dormant > interest after I found a poster over a few bird species in my mother's > weekly magazine when I was around 10 years old. > > RuneI use a surveyor's tripod (eBay; $50) that is more rigid than any portable mount I've seen in supplies for amateur astronomy intended for anything smaller than a 10-inch scope. It is lighter, folds more easily and smaller than the one I built and just as rigid. I use it for my 80-mm f/5 astronomical refractor (eBay; $50. augmented with a $37 2" focuser) that is both a rich-field scope and what I take bird pictures with. Interchangeable lenses and T-mount (came as part of the 2" focuser) make it very versatile. I was surprised to find that the objective is so close to diffraction limited that I can't tell the difference. With a 5 mm eyepiece, the image of a star -- we do see some around here once in a while -- has symmetrical in and out out-of-focus patterns, while the first Airy dark ring is just hinted at in focus. I'm happy with both instruments. The 80 mm is f/5, while the 125mm is f/10 bare and f/6.3 with an adapter that also flattens the field for 35mm photography. They make fine telephoto lenses for an aperture-priority camera. I'll write more about the tripod and the attachments I made to use it with all my instruments (including any camera with 1/4" thread) if it pleases anyone to know. All can be duplicated with access to a small lathe. Most could be made, although a bit differently, with hand tools. Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
Power spectrum
Started by ●July 10, 2005
Reply by ●July 14, 20052005-07-14
Reply by ●July 15, 20052005-07-15
Jerry Avins wrote:> Rune Allnor wrote: > > > > Jerry Avins wrote: > > > > > >>The seeing here is so poor what with smog and urban lights, that I > >>haven't been able to see much for a few years. I brought my 80 mm to > >>Berkeley, CA, expecting to spend a few days at Inverness on Point Reyes, > >>but that didn't happen and it rained (out of season; everything is out > >>of season including hurricanes) most of the time. For all the good the > >>C5 does me, you might as well have it. > > > > > > Well, I bought my telescope because I always have been very interested > > in astronomy. The problem is that in my neck of the woods, there would > > be like 60 clear nights per year, 40 of them in the summer season where > > > > there are but one star (the sun) to be seen. Buying an astro telescope > > that potentially can be used 10 - 20 nights per year, just doesn't make > > > > sense. > > > > So instead of buying a specialist tool to be used once in a blue moon, > > I bought a spotting scope that could double (at least to some extent) > > as a astronomy scope. The spotting scope works reasonably well for the > > moon and the major planets, but that's about it. Perhaps it's the > > seeing > > that is to poor, or I just don't want to mess around with no finder > > scope and standard tripod mount. Whatever the reason for not doing > > astronomy, I discovered birding, which seems to have been a dormant > > interest after I found a poster over a few bird species in my mother's > > weekly magazine when I was around 10 years old. > > > > Rune > > I use a surveyor's tripod (eBay; $50) that is more rigid than any > portable mount I've seen in supplies for amateur astronomy intended for > anything smaller than a 10-inch scope. It is lighter, folds more easily > and smaller than the one I built and just as rigid.What weights are we talking about? I got a rigid camera tripod that weighs in at some 3 kg, plus a 1.5 - 2 kg video head. It's very sturdy and there is no vibration to be seen when panning, but at 5 kg (plus a 1.5 kg scope + 1 - 2 kg of accessories), this is a bulky load to haul in the field. I very sedom haul the kit more than 50 - 100 m from my car. That said, it is usually great rewards to be had if one does haul the kit to, say, "the lake just beyond the next hill".> I use it for my > 80-mm f/5 astronomical refractor (eBay; $50. augmented with a $37 2" > focuser) that is both a rich-field scope and what I take bird pictures > with. Interchangeable lenses and T-mount (came as part of the 2" > focuser) make it very versatile.For some reason I have the impression that astro scopes are very "fragile" stuff. Precision and incredible optics is obtained at the expense of robustness. My spotting scope is "beefed up" with armour and padding, and with very sturdy bayonet locks for the eyepieces. Would your kit survive a trip in the field? In the wet climate of the atlantic coast, I'd expect non-protected otics to "fog up". It is, in fact, a problem when I am out in 12 - 15C and foggy weather. The heat of my face near the eyepiece heats the air enough to cause the cold surface of the eyepiece lens to fog. If somebody have a way to prevent this from happening, I'm all ears.> I was surprised to find that the > objective is so close to diffraction limited that I can't tell the > difference. With a 5 mm eyepiece, the image of a star -- we do see some > around here once in a while -- has symmetrical in and out out-of-focus > patterns, while the first Airy dark ring is just hinted at in focus. I'm > happy with both instruments.I used to lurk on sci.astro.amateur, and apparently, lense optics (as opposed to mirror optics) is the "best", in the sense of being diffraction limited and providing the best f ratio. Lense optics is, apparently, very expensive to build and cumbersome to operate, beyound some 120 - 150 mm objective aperture.> The 80 mm is f/5, while the 125mm is f/10 > bare and f/6.3 with an adapter that also flattens the field for 35mm > photography. They make fine telephoto lenses for an aperture-priority > camera. > > I'll write more about the tripod and the attachments I made to use it > with all my instruments (including any camera with 1/4" thread) if it > pleases anyone to know. All can be duplicated with access to a small > lathe. Most could be made, although a bit differently, with hand tools.I'm all ears (or eyes) for what you have to tell. My 4-year-old nephew got a book about space travel and the planets. The book contained a most spectacular image of Saturn. It made a great impression on him when I told him I had used my spotting scope (which he is becoming quite good at operating) to see Saturn. Since then, he has seen "big round things" all over the place. Rune
Reply by ●July 15, 20052005-07-15
Rune Allnor wrote:> > Jerry Avins wrote:...>>I use a surveyor's tripod (eBay; $50) that is more rigid than any >>portable mount I've seen in supplies for amateur astronomy intended for >>anything smaller than a 10-inch scope. It is lighter, folds more easily >>and smaller than the one I built and just as rigid. > > > What weights are we talking about? I got a rigid camera tripod that > weighs in at some 3 kg, plus a 1.5 - 2 kg video head. It's very sturdy > and there is no vibration to be seen when panning, but at 5 kg (plus a > 1.5 kg scope + 1 - 2 kg of accessories), this is a bulky load to haul > in the field. I very sedom haul the kit more than 50 - 100 m from > my car. That said, it is usually great rewards to be had if one does > haul the kit to, say, "the lake just beyond the next hill".Tripod, shoulder strap, and tilt-pan head together weigh 12.5 lbs, about 5.7 Kg. The mount is stiff enough to allow 200 power (with the larger scope) in a light breeze. ...> For some reason I have the impression that astro scopes are very > "fragile" stuff. Precision and incredible optics is obtained at > the expense of robustness. My spotting scope is "beefed up" with > armour and padding, and with very sturdy bayonet locks for the > eyepieces. Would your kit survive a trip in the field? In the wet > climate of the atlantic coast, I'd expect non-protected otics to > "fog up". It is, in fact, a problem when I am out in 12 - 15C and > foggy weather. The heat of my face near the eyepiece heats the air > enough to cause the cold surface of the eyepiece lens to fog. If > somebody have a way to prevent this from happening, I'm all ears.My 80 mm stayed astro clear of fog when an 80mm spotting scope fogged up. It has a long hood (I wish it were removable) that I lined with wool cloth. I have an attachable hood for the larger scope that has a heater in it that's rarely needed because the hood alone usually suffices. As for robustness, I don't have a problem -- yet. ...> I used to lurk on sci.astro.amateur, and apparently, lense optics > (as opposed to mirror optics) is the "best", in the sense of being > diffraction limited and providing the best f ratio. Lense optics is, > apparently, very expensive to build and cumbersome to operate, > beyound some 120 - 150 mm objective aperture.The need for a secondary mirror in most reflecting designs created a central stop that is clearly visible out of focus and creates extra diffracting edges, lowering contrast. It's usually worth it for compactness, particularly for most photography, where contrast can be adjusted in the developing. The central stop of a Schmidt sky survey camera is huge; it it the film itself. It is about f/.9. No refractor could do its job. There is no "best" f number. Once, f/15 refractors were common. The small relative aperture minimized secondary color. Apochtomatic objectives were often f/10, but now, improved optical glass allows achromats to match them. Rich-field telescopes are best at f/5. I added a 2" focuser to mine and made an adapter for a WW II surplus 32mm Erfle with a 48 mm field lens. Magnificent!> I'm all ears (or eyes) for what you have to tell. My 4-year-old nephew > got a book about space travel and the planets. The book contained a > most spectacular image of Saturn. It made a great impression on him > when I told him I had used my spotting scope (which he is becoming > quite good at operating) to see Saturn. Since then, he has seen "big > round things" all over the place.There are far better resources than I for general astronomy information. I can tell you about constructing simple stuff to make inexpensive parts work well. (The Erfle eyepiece mount was once a plumbing fitting.) Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●July 15, 20052005-07-15
Jerry Avins wrote: ...> My 80 mm stayed astro clear of fog when an 80mm spotting scope fogged > up. ...Arrgh! My 80 mm astro stayed clear of fog when an 80mm spotting scope fogged up. Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Jerry Avins wrote:> Rune Allnor wrote: > > I used to lurk on sci.astro.amateur, and apparently, lense optics > > (as opposed to mirror optics) is the "best", in the sense of being > > diffraction limited and providing the best f ratio. Lense optics is, > > apparently, very expensive to build and cumbersome to operate, > > beyound some 120 - 150 mm objective aperture. > > The need for a secondary mirror in most reflecting designs created a > central stop that is clearly visible out of focus and creates extra > diffracting edges, lowering contrast. It's usually worth it for > compactness, particularly for most photography, where contrast can be > adjusted in the developing. The central stop of a Schmidt sky survey > camera is huge; it it the film itself. It is about f/.9. No refractor > could do its job. > > There is no "best" f number.You are right. As usual, I don't have a clue what I am talking about.> Once, f/15 refractors were common. The > small relative aperture minimized secondary color. Apochtomatic > objectives were often f/10, but now, improved optical glass allows > achromats to match them. Rich-field telescopes are best at f/5. I added > a 2" focuser to mine and made an adapter for a WW II surplus 32mm Erfle > with a 48 mm field lens. Magnificent!Just a teaser for the artistically inclined: I used a small make-up mirror (must be convex, not flat), it cost me the equivalent of $5, to improvise a camera obscura. It worked very well in the darkest room in the house, with sunlight lighting up the next room. The projector I made from a simple magnifying glass worked, too, but in this case the image was a bit too small to trace on paper. Try it. With a little bit of preparation, one can make lifelike drawing and paintings. Rune
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Rune Allnor wrote: ...> Just a teaser for the artistically inclined: I used a small make-up > mirror (must be convex, not flat), it cost me the equivalent of $5, > to improvise a camera obscura. It worked very well in the darkest > room in the house, with sunlight lighting up the next room. The > projector I made from a simple magnifying glass worked, too, but > in this case the image was a bit too small to trace on paper. > > Try it. With a little bit of preparation, one can make lifelike > drawing and paintings.Most magnifiers have too short a focal length to make a large enough image, as you discovered. (A 3X magnifier is about 85 mm.) You can get surplus achromats from http://www.surplusshed.com (1) pretty cheap. They seem to have taken over the stock of Edmund Scientific and have a lot of good stuff. (I use http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l1657.html with excellent results as a Wolrab* lens to increase the field of view of a 1/3" video camera used as an eyepiece. Achromats not only minimize color, but spherical aberration and coma as well. They aren't very good for wide-angle use (but better than most simple lenses) in a camera obscura. They can be made quite good by using a pair of twice the desired focal length mounted back to back (more convex sides out) with a diaphragm between them. (If this stuff interests you, read Conrady, from Dover.) A pair of http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l3034.html might make a decent CO lens. A surplus copier lens might be even better, and there are plenty of those around. A fine example, better and cheaper than a roll-my-own is http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l3297.html. Lenses are a little like logic chips in that they can be used in combination to do neat stuff. _____________________________________ 1) I emailed them some says ago to point out a broken link in a web page, and mentioned (just to get it off my chest) that the French barometer I had gotten from them a few moths ago never worked, which disappointed but didn't surprise me. This morning's mail included an unsolicited replacement, one that seems to work! Hats is off to them! 2) Barlow spelled backwards; my own coinage. (The lens was originally an image erector, I presume from a rifle scope.) -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Jerry Avins wrote:> Rune Allnor wrote: > > ... > > > Just a teaser for the artistically inclined: I used a small make-up > > mirror (must be convex, not flat), it cost me the equivalent of $5, > > to improvise a camera obscura. It worked very well in the darkest > > room in the house, with sunlight lighting up the next room. The > > projector I made from a simple magnifying glass worked, too, but > > in this case the image was a bit too small to trace on paper. > > > > Try it. With a little bit of preparation, one can make lifelike > > drawing and paintings. > > Most magnifiers have too short a focal length to make a large enough > image, as you discovered. (A 3X magnifier is about 85 mm.) You can get > surplus achromats from http://www.surplusshed.com (1) pretty cheap. They > seem to have taken over the stock of Edmund Scientific and have a lot of > good stuff. (I use http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l1657.html with > excellent results as a Wolrab* lens to increase the field of view of a > 1/3" video camera used as an eyepiece. Achromats not only minimize > color, but spherical aberration and coma as well. They aren't very good > for wide-angle use (but better than most simple lenses) in a camera > obscura. They can be made quite good by using a pair of twice the > desired focal length mounted back to back (more convex sides out) with a > diaphragm between them. (If this stuff interests you, read Conrady, from > Dover.) A pair of http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l3034.html might > make a decent CO lens. A surplus copier lens might be even better, and > there are plenty of those around. A fine example, better and cheaper > than a roll-my-own is http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/l3297.html. > > Lenses are a little like logic chips in that they can be used in > combination to do neat stuff.I am sure you are right and it would be great fun to test out some of the basic optical principles. Somehow, it seems to me that some precision tools and mechanical skills, like knowing how to operating a lathe, would be needed. My own ambition with the camera obscura is "merely" to make a small, simple teaser to demonstrate the basic physics of optics for the kids in the neighbourhood. I know some of them like to play with drawing and painting, and making a quick portrait with a CO[*] (and then showing them how it worked) might just be what would trig some interest of physics. Or what tags me as "the mad scientist" once and for all, if it hasn't happened already... Rune [*] The inspiration to play with the CO came from a program I saw on the "BBC learning" TV channel, where some art historian presented the hypothesis that the great revolution of the reneissance "photographic" painting, Brunelleschi's (or was it Boticellis's?) development of perspective etc., were based on the advent of high-quality optics, mirrors and lenses. The historian went on to demonstrate, with very simple means, how he thaught Caravaggio would have worked, and also pointed out "flaws" in various paintings ("out of focus" regions, distorted proporsions) that he explained in terms of makeshift solutions for using the optics to make large paintings. The whole story made sense to me, so I decided to try for myself. It seems to work, although I haven't tried to draw anything with this method. Yet.
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Rune Allnor wrote:> > Jerry Avins wrote:...>>Lenses are a little like logic chips in that they can be used in >>combination to do neat stuff. > > > I am sure you are right and it would be great fun to test out some > of the basic optical principles. Somehow, it seems to me that some > precision tools and mechanical skills, like knowing how to operating > a lathe, would be needed.A lathe is very nice, but you can do a lot with cardboard tubes, tin cans, stove pipe, wood, and hand tools. Given a mounted lens -- the mount can be cardboard -- wood, a piece of ground glass (or window glass and emery powder) and wood, a camera obscura is easy to make. A mirror can make it fancier. http://brightbytes.com/cosite/portable.html My first camera was a cardboard pinhole kit from Kodak. I won honorable mention in Popular Photography with a picture I took with it that took advantage of the tremendous depth of field and uniform slight softness. My first astro telescope, a 3" f/14 refractor had a surplus erecting roof prism with 1.25" clear aperture. The tube was stove pipe, the end fitting was a soup can soldered to a mixed-nut can with a press-on lid (with the prism inside) and a commercial focuser intended for a Newtonian refractor. The tube was lined with black flock paper. I cannibalized much of it for more other uses, but I still have the objective (with its tuna-can lens cap) Do you want it?> My own ambition with the camera obscura is "merely" to make a small, > simple teaser to demonstrate the basic physics of optics for the kids > in the neighbourhood. I know some of them like to play with drawing > and painting, and making a quick portrait with a CO[*] (and then > showing them how it worked) might just be what would trig some interest > of physics. Or what tags me as "the mad scientist" once and for all, > if it hasn't happened already...Then get the copier lens I pointed out (or any other you can find more locally; some have flanges) and use for inspiration the pictures at http://brightbytes.com/cosite/portable.html. Along with the broken barometer, I bought http://www.surplusshed.com/pages/item/m2071.html for my grandchildren. Searching for it is how I found the site. I recommend it strongly, especially at its close-out price.> Rune > > [*] The inspiration to play with the CO came from a program I saw > on the "BBC learning" TV channel, where some art historian > presented the hypothesis that the great revolution of the > reneissance "photographic" painting, Brunelleschi's (or was it > Boticellis's?) development of perspective etc., were based on > the advent of high-quality optics, mirrors and lenses. The > historian went on to demonstrate, with very simple means, how > he thaught Caravaggio would have worked, and also pointed out > "flaws" in various paintings ("out of focus" regions, distorted > proporsions) that he explained in terms of makeshift solutions > for using the optics to make large paintings. The whole story > made sense to me, so I decided to try for myself. It seems to > work, although I haven't tried to draw anything with this method. > Yet.That 45" focal length objective (airspaced, mounted) makes a dandy CO. I tried it. Coma is the most prominent aberration at large angles, bit it's worth seeing the images. F/15 is bright enough in a dark hut. Jerry -- Engineering is the art of making what you want from things you can get. �����������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●July 16, 20052005-07-16
Jerry Avins wrote:> Rune Allnor wrote: > > > > Jerry Avins wrote: > > > ... > > >>Lenses are a little like logic chips in that they can be used in > >>combination to do neat stuff. > > > > > > I am sure you are right and it would be great fun to test out some > > of the basic optical principles. Somehow, it seems to me that some > > precision tools and mechanical skills, like knowing how to operating > > a lathe, would be needed. > > A lathe is very nice, but you can do a lot with cardboard tubes, tin > cans, stove pipe, wood, and hand tools. Given a mounted lens -- the > mount can be cardboard -- wood, a piece of ground glass (or window glass > and emery powder) and wood, a camera obscura is easy to make. A mirror > can make it fancier. http://brightbytes.com/cosite/portable.html My > first camera was a cardboard pinhole kit from Kodak. I won honorable > mention in Popular Photography with a picture I took with it that took > advantage of the tremendous depth of field and uniform slight softness. > My first astro telescope, a 3" f/14 refractor had a surplus erecting > roof prism with 1.25" clear aperture. The tube was stove pipe, the end > fitting was a soup can soldered to a mixed-nut can with a press-on lid > (with the prism inside) and a commercial focuser intended for a > Newtonian refractor. The tube was lined with black flock paper. I > cannibalized much of it for more other uses, but I still have the > objective (with its tuna-can lens cap) Do you want it?Heyheyheyheyhey, you are light-years ahead of me... your CO was a box with lense in the front end and a matt glass "projector screen" in the rear end? Sure, it could be done but I'm thinking a bit simpler than that. What I have in mind is a small mirror, like the ~7 cm mirror I bought today, perhaps a bit bigger to collect more light, somehow mounted behind an easel inside a dark hut or room. No fancy stuff, just a mirror. The mount and the easel will be needed to keep the mirror and the drawing paper in fixed positions for any length of time, but that's obvious to anybody who sees the rig. Use some sticks or chairs an a couple of carpets to make a dark "tent", and perhaps rig some lights outside to light up the subject even more. The key here is to make people see each and every piece of the rig, undertsand why they are there and thus see how the whole thing works. The lense-and-projector-screen-inside-a-box would probably be too much of a "black box" - literally - to be useful to trig curiousity. But then, your method might just be what trigs the whole optics frenzie. Rune







