DSPRelated.com
Forums
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →

Amplitude response of a FIR Filter in Excel

Started by Web Surf ●January 27, 2006
Web Surf wrote:
> I am a guitarist trying to understand a bit more about this Guitar Effects > processor that I purchased 3 months ago. > > Here are some questions : > > 1) This new box appears to implement Loudspeaker cabinets as 136 tap > asymmetrical FIR filters. The earlier box implemented as 128 tap. > > 1.1) Is there any hardware reason to choose a number like 136 ? Any chips > that do 136 tap FIR Filters ? > > 1.2) From my attempts to plot frequency response, it appears that there is > no real benefit of having 8 taps more. Is that correct ? > > 2) While studying the method to plot FIR Filter response in Excel proposed > by some on this forum, it appears to me that a 128/136 tap filter with > 44100 Hz sampling cannot be flexible between 0-300 Hz. Ie all FIR filters > with above hardware will have same response below 300 Hz ( The first point > in the graph as per the proposed plotting methods which draws a straigh > line from 0 Hz to 300 Hz) > > Have I understood correctly ? > > Or is this a deficiency of the proposed plotting method.
try the demo version of QED1000 for FIR filter analysis http://www.mds.com/products/product.asp?prod=S002%2DW32 Mark
> >Web Surf wrote: >> I am a guitarist trying to understand a bit more about this Guitar
Effects
>> processor that I purchased 3 months ago. >> >> Here are some questions : >> >> 1) This new box appears to implement Loudspeaker cabinets as 136 tap >> asymmetrical FIR filters. The earlier box implemented as 128 tap. >> >> 1.1) Is there any hardware reason to choose a number like 136 ? Any
chips
>> that do 136 tap FIR Filters ? >> >> 1.2) From my attempts to plot frequency response, it appears that there
is
>> no real benefit of having 8 taps more. Is that correct ? >> >> 2) While studying the method to plot FIR Filter response in Excel
proposed
>> by some on this forum, it appears to me that a 128/136 tap filter with >> 44100 Hz sampling cannot be flexible between 0-300 Hz. Ie all FIR
filters
>> with above hardware will have same response below 300 Hz ( The first
point
>> in the graph as per the proposed plotting methods which draws a
straigh
>> line from 0 Hz to 300 Hz) >> >> Have I understood correctly ? >> >> Or is this a deficiency of the proposed plotting method. > > >try the demo version of QED1000 for FIR filter analysis > >http://www.mds.com/products/product.asp?prod=S002%2DW32 > >Mark > >
Thanks I had already downloaded QED2000 last month ( And about every other trial FIR designer out there) Even these s/w seem to indicate a straight line response below 300 Hz ie it appears to me that a 136 tap filter sampled at 44100 Hz cannot shape frequencies below about 300 Hz. In Excel, people guided me to plot the first point at 44100 Hz/ 136 taps = 344 Hz ie no effect of the FIR on freq below 344 Hz.
Web Surf wrote:
...
> > I had already downloaded QED2000 last month ( And about every other trial > FIR designer out there) > > Even these s/w seem to indicate a straight line response below 300 Hz ie > it appears to me that a 136 tap filter sampled at 44100 Hz cannot shape > frequencies below about 300 Hz.
I guess I'm not sure how you could have come to that conclusion. I tried this with ScopeFIR (whose Trial Edition you've no doubt tried ;-), and I found that the filter had the first null at about 324 Hz (=44100 / 136); therefore, there is significant attenuation nearby at 300 Hz--about 22 dB.
> In Excel, people guided me to plot the first point at 44100 Hz/ 136 taps = > 344 Hz ie no effect of the FIR on freq below 344 Hz.
Although Excel is a perfectly good tool for such analyses (if you don't mind its plots' pathetic and mysterious lack of multi-level mouse-based zooming even now, many years after the world's largest software company first foisted it on us and made it the most widely used product of its kind worldwide ;-) I think there must be some mistake in your formulas if you're coming to this conclusion. FWIW, a sample chapter from Harris's Multirate Book at http://www.phptr.com/articles/article.asp?p=361985&rl=1 talks a little about boxcar filters and provides a frequency response formula. =g2 -- _____________________________________________________________________ Grant R. Griffin Publisher of dspGuru http://www.dspguru.com Iowegian International Corporation http://www.iowegian.com See http://www.iowegian.com/img/contact.gif for e-mail address

> > Even these s/w seem to indicate a straight line response below 300 Hz ie > it appears to me that a 136 tap filter sampled at 44100 Hz cannot shape > frequencies below about 300 Hz.
You must have an error someplace.. and what do you mean by "straightline" Use QED to DESIGN a filter instead of analyzing the one you have... Mark