Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote: ...> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. > The amateurs call this a "threshold".You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur? Jerry -- "The rights of the best of men are secured only as the rights of the vilest and most abhorrent are protected." - Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, 1927 ���������������������������������������������������������������������
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
FM SNR theory
Started by ●October 26, 2006
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Jerry Avins wrote:> >> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. >> The amateurs call this a "threshold". > > > You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur?I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. Don't know about Schwarts, however if someone does not understand the distinction, then he is an amateur. Indeed, the "ideal case" performance of the FM can be derived. Vladimir Vassilevsky DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant http://www.abvolt.com
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote:> > > Randy Yates wrote: > >> John Sampson <johns@3db-labs.com> writes: >> >> >>> patrick.melet@dmradiocom.fr wrote: >>> >>>>> Pt = transmit carrier power A^2/2 >>>>> W = output LPF bandwidth >>>>> Fd = peak deviation >>>>> No = input noise density >>>>> m = modulating signal >>>>> >>>>> SNRo = 3 * mean(m^2) * (Fd / W)^2 * Pt / (No * W) >>>> >>>> so if my m signal is a sinus at 250 kHz with 1 V rms then mean(m^2) = >>>> 0.5 >>>> if my Fd = 250 kHz and W = 250 kHz then (Fd / W)^2 = 1 >>>> if Pt / (No * W) = SNR input, at the input at the modulator I simulate >>>> the SNR (measure it) >>>> then SNRo = 3 * 0.5 * 1 * SNRi = 1.5 * SNRi >>>> is it exact ? >>>> >>> >>> You should see SNRo > SNRi when the discriminator operates above >>> threshold (no clicks). This is called FM improvement. I've obtained >>> good agreement with the theory in the past. >> >> >> Hi John, >> >> If the discriminator is just dtheta/dt where theta is the phase of the >> analytic baseband signal, then what is the thing you call the >> "threshold?" Just curious. > > Hello Randy, > > The approximation quoted by John is valid on the two assumptions: > 1. SNR is high. 2. The detector is a dumb discriminator. > > We should distinguish the properties of the FM signal itself from the > inefficiency of the particular demodulator. > > The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. > The amateurs call this a "threshold". >So do the professionals. John
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Randy Yates wrote:> John Sampson <johns@3db-labs.com> writes: > >> patrick.melet@dmradiocom.fr wrote: >>>> Pt = transmit carrier power A^2/2 >>>> W = output LPF bandwidth >>>> Fd = peak deviation >>>> No = input noise density >>>> m = modulating signal >>>> >>>> SNRo = 3 * mean(m^2) * (Fd / W)^2 * Pt / (No * W) >>> so if my m signal is a sinus at 250 kHz with 1 V rms then mean(m^2) = >>> 0.5 >>> if my Fd = 250 kHz and W = 250 kHz then (Fd / W)^2 = 1 >>> if Pt / (No * W) = SNR input, at the input at the modulator I simulate >>> the SNR (measure it) >>> then SNRo = 3 * 0.5 * 1 * SNRi = 1.5 * SNRi >>> is it exact ? >>> >> You should see SNRo > SNRi when the discriminator operates above >> threshold (no clicks). This is called FM improvement. I've obtained >> good agreement with the theory in the past. > > Hi John, > > If the discriminator is just dtheta/dt where theta is the phase of the > analytic baseband signal, then what is the thing you call the > "threshold?" Just curious.If you lower the power of the FM signal entering the discriminator, the "below threshold" region is entered when clicks begin to appear in the output. This is the point at which the slope of the SNRo vs SNRi curve changes. John
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote:> > > Jerry Avins wrote: > >> >>> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. >>> The amateurs call this a "threshold". >> >> >> You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur? > > I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM > from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. Don't know about > Schwarts, however if someone does not understand the distinction, then > he is an amateur. > Indeed, the "ideal case" performance of the FM can be derived.The notion of threshold has been around for a long time. See, for example, M. G. Crosby, "Frequency Modulation Noise Characteristics", Ptoc. IRE, vol. 25, pp 472-514, April 1937. Jerry -- "The rights of the best of men are secured only as the rights of the vilest and most abhorrent are protected." - Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, 1927 ���������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●October 26, 20062006-10-26
Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote:> Jerry Avins wrote: > > > > >> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. > >> The amateurs call this a "threshold". > > > > > > You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur? > > I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM > from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. Don't know about > Schwarts, however if someone does not understand the distinction, then > he is an amateur. > Indeed, the "ideal case" performance of the FM can be derived. >Is the threshold effect a function of the inefficiency of a particular demodulator or is the threshold effect an inherent theoretical function of FM? Does not even the "ideal case" FM demodulator exhibit a "threshold"? Yes, I know diffrent demodulators have diffrent thresholds and "threshold extension" is an interesting topic but I thought even an ideal FM demodulator would have a threshold. Mark
Reply by ●October 27, 20062006-10-27
The threshold of FM demodulator is for every type of demodulator implementation. To demodulate an FM signal you need to differentiate the phase over time. At low SNR the trajectory of the phase can cross the origin (zero amplitude) on the wrong side (due to noise). This create a click. The threshold is the SNR where this phenomena start occurring often. Here is a simple example. In a sampled signal if the phase is going from 0 to 45 degree in two steps 0, 22.5 and 45 degree. Let assume that the SNR is very low and the path from 0 to 45 degree cross the origin at the middle step and it is interpreted as 202.5 degree. This will result in a click (large amplitude spike at the output of the demodulator). LM "Mark" <makolber@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:1161913052.959362.179710@k70g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...> > Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote: >> Jerry Avins wrote: >> >> > >> >> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. >> >> The amateurs call this a "threshold". >> > >> > >> > You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur? >> >> I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM >> from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. Don't know about >> Schwarts, however if someone does not understand the distinction, then >> he is an amateur. >> Indeed, the "ideal case" performance of the FM can be derived. >> > > Is the threshold effect a function of the inefficiency of a particular > demodulator or is the threshold effect an inherent theoretical function > of FM? Does not even the "ideal case" FM demodulator exhibit a > "threshold"? > > Yes, I know diffrent demodulators have diffrent thresholds and > "threshold extension" is an interesting topic but I thought even an > ideal FM demodulator would have a threshold. > > Mark >
Reply by ●October 27, 20062006-10-27
Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote:> > > Jerry Avins wrote: > >> >>> The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. >>> The amateurs call this a "threshold". >> >> >> >> You think Mischa Schwartz is an amateur? > > > I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM > from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. Don't know about > Schwarts, however if someone does not understand the distinction, then > he is an amateur. > Indeed, the "ideal case" performance of the FM can be derived. >Is there such a derivation on the web? I'd be interested in reading it -- IIRC my Van Trees just gives some upper & lower bounds, not a theoretical best performance. -- Tim Wescott Wescott Design Services http://www.wescottdesign.com Posting from Google? See http://cfaj.freeshell.org/google/ "Applied Control Theory for Embedded Systems" came out in April. See details at http://www.wescottdesign.com/actfes/actfes.html
Reply by ●October 27, 20062006-10-27
Vladimir Vassilevsky wrote: (snip)> The approximation quoted by John is valid on the two assumptions: > 1. SNR is high. 2. The detector is a simple discriminator.> We should distinguish the properties of the FM signal itself from the > inefficiency of the particular demodulator.> The discriminator fails when the normalized SNR falls below ~10dB. The > popular word for this is a "threshold".I used to read about TV satellite signals, the big dish ones, not the small dish ones now popular for home use. If I remember, they broadcast something like six watts/channel spread over most of the US, and probably some of the ocean. They depend on what I believe is called the "FM advantage" to get a reasonable SNR out. Something like 25dB better than they would otherwise get. -- glen
Reply by ●October 27, 20062006-10-27
Mark wrote:>>I think that we should distinguish the theoretical performance of the FM >>from the inefficiency of the particular demodulator. > > Is the threshold effect a function of the inefficiency of a particular > demodulator or is the threshold effect an inherent theoretical function > of FM? Does not even the "ideal case" FM demodulator exhibit a > "threshold"?Good question. Consider the FM signal with the deviation (-Fd,+Fd) and the modulation signal bandwidth (0,Fs). Assume the modulation signal already has the uniform statistics. It is definitely not the case with the audio signal, however the predictability is the different question and we are not going to consider it at this time. The noise is additive gaussian. The ideal FM demodulator is solving the following problem: estimate the most likely frequency of the carrier in the range of (-Fd,+Fd) based on the observation of the input on the duration of 1/Fs. There are two cases here: a) The power of the noise in the bandwidth (0,Fs) is comparable to the power of the signal. In this case the frequency estimate error will look like the erf(input SNR), i.e. exponential type dependence. The noise at the output is white and uniformly distributed. b) The power of the noise in the bandwidth (0,Fs) is much smaller then the power of the signal. The output error is directly proportional to the input SNR (linear dependence). The noise at the output is white gaussian. Where do those cases met? (-Fd,+Fd) Here is a coarse estimate: SNR ~ 3 --------- (0,Fs) Note: the SNR is defined as the ratio of the RMS input signal to the RMS noise in the bandwidth (0,Fs). We can call this SNR value the threshold of the ideal FM demodulator. I let the others to elaborate on the exact numbers.> > Yes, I know diffrent demodulators have diffrent thresholds and > "threshold extension" is an interesting topic but I thought even an > ideal FM demodulator would have a threshold. > > MarkVladimir Vassilevsky DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant http://www.abvolt.com







