Vladimir Vassilevsky <antispam_bogus@hotmail.com> writes:> Randy Yates wrote: > >> John Sampson <johns@3db-labs.com> writes: >> >>>patrick.melet@dmradiocom.fr wrote: >>> >>>>>Pt = transmit carrier power A^2/2 >>>>>W = output LPF bandwidth >>>>>Fd = peak deviation >>>>>No = input noise density >>>>>m = modulating signal >>>>> >>>>>SNRo = 3 * mean(m^2) * (Fd / W)^2 * Pt / (No * W) >>>> >>>>so if my m signal is a sinus at 250 kHz with 1 V rms then mean(m^2) = >>>>0.5 >>>>if my Fd = 250 kHz and W = 250 kHz then (Fd / W)^2 = 1 >>>>if Pt / (No * W) = SNR input, at the input at the modulator I simulate >>>>the SNR (measure it) >>>>then SNRo = 3 * 0.5 * 1 * SNRi = 1.5 * SNRi >>>>is it exact ? >>>> >>> >>>You should see SNRo > SNRi when the discriminator operates above >>>threshold (no clicks). This is called FM improvement. I've obtained >>>good agreement with the theory in the past. >> Hi John, >> If the discriminator is just dtheta/dt where theta is the phase of >> the >> analytic baseband signal, then what is the thing you call the >> "threshold?" Just curious. > > Hello Randy, > > The approximation quoted by John is valid on the two assumptions: > 1. SNR is high. 2. The detector is a dumb discriminator. > > We should distinguish the properties of the FM signal itself from the > inefficiency of the particular demodulator. > > The discriminator goofs up when the normalized SNR falls below > ~10dB. The amateurs call this a "threshold".Hi Vladimir, I don't doubt that your statements are true, but I want to understand why they are true. I've been trying to find the time to review FM theory, e.g., in [schwartzcomm], to find out why. --Randy @book{schwartzcomm, title = "Information Transmission, Modulation, and Noise", author = "{Mischa~Schwartz}", publisher = "McGraw-Hill", edition = "fourth", year = "1975"} -- % Randy Yates % "Bird, on the wing, %% Fuquay-Varina, NC % goes floating by %%% 919-577-9882 % but there's a teardrop in his eye..." %%%% <yates@ieee.org> % 'One Summer Dream', *Face The Music*, ELO http://home.earthlink.net/~yatescr
Online · Live + on demand
February 9-11, 2027
Price goes up Jan 1: register now to lock in today's rate
Register Now →
FM SNR theory
Started by ●October 26, 2006
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Randy Yates wrote:>>>>>To demodulate an FM signal you need to differentiate the >>>>>phase over time. >>>> >>>>This is not right. The task is to measure the frequency. You don't have >>>>to differentiate the phase to do that.^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Think about this.>>>You are confusing phase modulation with FM. You need a differentiator of >>>sorts. >>No. There is absolutely no need for the differentiator. > > > Vladimir, > > Since f = d\theta / dt, and how can you say there is no need for a > differentiator? How else would you recover an estimate of the original > information signal if you didn't somehow determine the frequency of > the modulated signal?I am not arguing the fact that the frequency is the derivative of the phase. What I am saying is there is no need to differentiate the phase since you can find the frequency directly. Vladimir Vassilevsky DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant http://www.abvolt.com
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Randy Yates <yates@ieee.org> writes:> @book{schwartzcomm, > title = "Information Transmission, Modulation, and Noise", > author = "{Mischa~Schwartz}", > publisher = "McGraw-Hill", > edition = "fourth", > year = "1975"}This year is wrong - should be 1990. Sorry for the misquote. -- % Randy Yates % "Midnight, on the water... %% Fuquay-Varina, NC % I saw... the ocean's daughter." %%% 919-577-9882 % 'Can't Get It Out Of My Head' %%%% <yates@ieee.org> % *El Dorado*, Electric Light Orchestra http://home.earthlink.net/~yatescr
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Randy Yates wrote:> I don't doubt that your statements are true, but I want > to understand why they are true.You may think of finding maximum of the Fourier transorm of the input signal.> I've been trying to > find the time to review FM theory, e.g., in [schwartzcomm], > to find out why.This is the classical problem of the estimation of the frequency of the signal in the presence of noise. I beleive it is treated in many books on radars and statistical radiotechnics. Vladimir Vassilevsky DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant http://www.abvolt.com
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Randy Yates wrote:> Randy Yates <yates@ieee.org> writes: > >> @book{schwartzcomm, >> title = "Information Transmission, Modulation, and Noise", >> author = "{Mischa~Schwartz}", >> publisher = "McGraw-Hill", >> edition = "fourth", >> year = "1975"} > > This year is wrong - should be 1990. Sorry for the misquote.I an so out of date! my edition is the first, 1959. (New price: $10.84 at the college bookstore.) I suppose that the process of differentiation is implied by inductors (v=L*di/dt) and capacitors (i = 1/C*dv/dt), so in that sense, even discriminators imply differentiation. But such subtleties aside, it is possible to measure frequency directly without measuring phase. Indeed, frequency is often much easier to measure than phase. A simple counter may suffice. Jerry -- "The rights of the best of men are secured only as the rights of the vilest and most abhorrent are protected." - Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, 1927 ���������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
"Vladimir Vassilevsky" <antispam_bogus@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:xK31h.17622$TV3.7868@newssvr21.news.prodigy.com...> > > Randy Yates wrote: > > >>>>>To demodulate an FM signal you need to differentiate the > >>>>>phase over time. > >>>> > >>>>This is not right. The task is to measure the frequency. You don'thave> >>>>to differentiate the phase to do that. >^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^> > Think about this. > > > >>>You are confusing phase modulation with FM. You need a differentiatorof> >>>sorts. > >>No. There is absolutely no need for the differentiator. > > > > > > Vladimir, > > > > Since f = d\theta / dt, and how can you say there is no need for a > > differentiator? How else would you recover an estimate of the original > > information signal if you didn't somehow determine the frequency of > > the modulated signal? > > I am not arguing the fact that the frequency is the derivative of the > phase. What I am saying is there is no need to differentiate the phase > since you can find the frequency directly. > > Vladimir Vassilevsky > > DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant > > http://www.abvolt.com >If you use zero crossings to count the freq then you get messed up by noise. M. -- Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Major Misunderstanding wrote:>>I am not arguing the fact that the frequency is the derivative of the >>phase. What I am saying is there is no need to differentiate the phase >>since you can find the frequency directly. >> > If you use zero crossings to count the freq then you get messed up by noise. >You are too ignorant to be interesting to talk with and I am too tired to explain the 2 + 2 = 4 for free. Let's make a bet: In one week, I will post here the C++ souce of the FM demodulator with near theoretical performance and without any phase differentiation. You pay me $5,000. Otherwise I pay you $5,000. How about that? Vladimir Vassilevsky DSP and Mixed Signal Design Consultant http://www.abvolt.com
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Major Misunderstanding wrote: ...> If you use zero crossings to count the freq then you get messed up by noise.... There are many ways to avoid that. High gain, hard limiting, slew-rate limiting, and hysteresis on the limiter's output is one way. There's no need to know the zero crossings times, just their count. Jerry -- "The rights of the best of men are secured only as the rights of the vilest and most abhorrent are protected." - Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, 1927 ���������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●October 29, 20062006-10-29
Jerry Avins wrote: ...> There are many ways to avoid that. High gain, hard limiting, slew-rate > limiting, and hysteresis on the limiter's output is one way. There's no > need to know the zero crossings times, just their count.P.S. If the IF into a frequency discriminator is hard limited -- the usual practice -- thereby converting the signal to a sequence of variable-width pulses, is that not a form of digital signal manipulation? -- "I view the progress of science as ... the slow erosion of the tendency to dichotomize." Barbara Smuts, U. Mich. ���������������������������������������������������������������������
Reply by ●October 30, 20062006-10-30
On Sun, 29 Oct 2006 15:44:12 GMT, Vladimir Vassilevsky <antispam_bogus@hotmail.com> wrote:> > >Randy Yates wrote: > >> I don't doubt that your statements are true, but I want >> to understand why they are true. > >You may think of finding maximum of the Fourier transorm of the input >signal.That seems like an incredibly inefficient way to demodulate FM.>> I've been trying to >> find the time to review FM theory, e.g., in [schwartzcomm], >> to find out why. > >This is the classical problem of the estimation of the frequency of the >signal in the presence of noise. I beleive it is treated in many books >on radars and statistical radiotechnics.And there is the usual problem of the time-frequency uncertainty principle. Clearly one can throw tons of complexity at the problem until the time resolution suits the application, but that's hardly an efficient engineering tradeoff. I think what Randy and others have had in mind are improvements or alternatives to the usual efficient techniques. Eric Jacobsen Minister of Algorithms, Intel Corp. My opinions may not be Intel's opinions. http://www.ericjacobsen.org







