Sure, this is absolutely correct in a musical context. So, let's agree on expanding the original definition a bit by including the case of abruptly changing parameters during playing of the instrument to also produce transients. That would include volume, pitch etc. and should give us what we need. :-) I think we should omit the attack/decay/sustain/release phase discussion altogether since it's a definition coined by the music industry to label playback phases when simulating instruments. Since they usually treat successive notes separately for technical reasons, the transition between notes isn't actually a problem - the release phase of the old note would be where the attack phase of the new note is... And I'd say that for the definition of "transient" the playback phase isn't relevant anyway. --smb Jerry Avins <jya@ieee.org> wrote:> But Stephan, That is how a piano is normally played. It's the sound > we've come to expect. Whether it's best thought of an ending transient > or a new attack would be an interesting discussion over a glass of beer. > Of course, pianos have sustain pedals, but releasing the pedal damps > many notes simultaneously. Even guitar and viol strings are rarely > allowed to decay completely before the next notes on them are played. > Consider even a trill on a flute. There is only one air column, so one > note must stop as abruptly as the other note starts. > > Jerry
transient
Started by ●June 7, 2004
Reply by ●June 11, 20042004-06-11