# Design IIR Butterworth Filters Using 12 Lines of Code

While there are plenty of canned functions to design Butterworth IIR filters [1], it’s instructive and not that complicated to design them from scratch. You can do it in 12 lines of Matlab code. In this article, we’ll create a Matlab function butter_synth.m to design lowpass Butterworth filters of any order. Here is an example function call for a 5^{th} order filter:

N= 5 % Filter order fc= 10; % Hz cutoff freq fs= 100; % Hz sample freq [b,a]= butter_synth(N,fc,fs) b = 0.0013 0.0064 0.0128 0.0128 0.0064 0.0013 a = 1.0000 -2.9754 3.8060 -2.5453 0.8811 -0.1254

Then, to find the frequency response:

[h,f]= freqz(b,a,256,fs); H= 20*log10(abs(h));

The magnitude response of the 5^{th} order filter is shown in Figure 1, along with the response of the analog prototype.

Figure 1. Magnitude response of N= 5 IIR Butterworth filter with f_{c} = 10 Hz and f_{s} = 100 Hz. The prototype analog filter’s response is also shown.

## Notation

First, a word about notation. We need to distinguish frequency variables in the continuous-time (analog) world from those in the discrete-time world. In this article, the following notation for frequency will be used:

continuous frequency F Hz

continuous radian frequency Ω radians/s

complex frequency s = σ + jΩ

discrete frequency f Hz

discrete normalized radian frequency ω = 2πf/f_{s}radians, where f_{s} = sample freq

## Background

Analog Butterworth filters have all-pole transfer functions. For example, a third-order Butterworth filter with Ω_{c} = 1 rad/s has the transfer function:

$$H(s)=\frac{1}{s^3+2s^2+2s+1}$$

or

$$H(s)=\frac{1}{(s-p_{a0})(s-p_{a1})(s-p_{a2}) }\qquad(1)$$

where the subscript *a* denotes analog (s-plane) poles. The poles in the s-plane are:

p_{a0} = -.5 + j.866

p_{a1} = -1

p_{a2} = -.5 -j.866

We will transform the poles in the s-plane to poles in the z-plane using the bilinear transform [2,3]. The bilinear transform converts H(s) to H(z) by replacing* s* with:

$$s=2f_s\frac{1-z^{-1}}{1+z^{-1}}\qquad(2)$$

where f_{s} is sample frequency. If we solve for z, we get:

$$z=\frac{1+s/(2f_s)}{1-s/(2f_s)}\qquad(3)$$

Equation 3 maps a point on the s plane to a point on the z plane. For example, if f_{s}= 2 Hz, the s-plane real pole at -1 maps to:

$$p=\frac{1-1/4}{1+1/4}=0.6$$

For the 3^{rd} order filter, with Ω_{c}= 1 and f_{s}= 2, the z-plane poles fall as shown in Figure 2.

From equation 1, H(s) has 3 zeros at s= ∞. How do they map to the z plane? We will show later that the bilinear transform maps -∞ to ∞ on the jΩ axis to -f_{s}/2 to f_{s}/2 on the unit circle. So the 3 zeros of H(s) map to +/- f_{s}/2 on the unit circle, which corresponds to z= -1. (Recall that on the unit circle, z= e^{jω}, where ω = 2πf/f_{s}. For f = +/-f_{s}/2, we have ω = +/-π, so z = e^{jπ} = -1). The three zeros are represented by the ‘o’ in figure 2.

We can now write the 3^{rd}-order Butterworth H(z) as:

$$H(z)=K\frac{(z+1)(z+1)(z+1)}{(z-p_0)(z-p_1)(z-p_2)}\qquad(4)$$

where, from equation 3, p= [0.7143 +j 0.33 0.6 0.7143 -j 0.33]. Expanding the numerator and denominator, we have:

$$H(z)=K\frac{b_0z^3+b_1z^2+b_2z+b_3}{z^3+a_1z^2+a_2z+a_3}$$

$$H(z)=K\frac{b_0+b_1z^{-1}+b_2z^{-2}+b_3z^{-3}}{1+a_1z^{-1}+a_2z^{-2}+a_3z^{-3}}\qquad(5)$$

Where b = [1 3 3 1] and a= [1 -2.0286 1.4762 -0.3714]. K is chosen to make gain = 1 at ω= 0: K = 1/H(ω=0) = 1/H(z=1) = sum(a)/sum(b)= .00952

Looking again at Figure 1, you may have wondered why the attenuation of the IIR filter is greater than that of the analog filter as f approaches f_{s}/2. The reason is that the analog filter’s zeros are at ∞, while the bilinear transform compresses the frequency scale so that the IIR filter’s zeros are at f_{s}/2.

Figure 2. Z-plane Poles and zeros of 3^{rd} order IIR Butterworth filter with Ω_{c}= 1 and f_{s}= 2.

## Filter Synthesis

Here is a summary of the steps for finding the filter coefficients :

- Find the poles of the analog prototype filter with Ω
_{c}= 1 rad/s. - Given the desired f
_{c}of the digital filter, find the corresponding analog frequency F_{c}. - Scale the s-plane poles by 2πF
_{c}. - Transform the poles from the s-plane to the z-plane.
- Add N zeros at z = -1.
- Convert poles and zeros to polynomials with coefficients a
_{n}and b_{n}.

Now let’s look at the steps in detail. Note we’ll repeat a lot of the math we already presented above. A Matlab function butter_synth that performs the filter synthesis is provided in the Appendix. It gives the same results as the built-in Matlab function butter(n,Wn) [1].

1. Poles of the analog filter. For a Butterworth filter of order N with Ω_{c} = 1 rad/s, the poles are given by [4,5]:

$$p_{ak}= -sin(\theta)+jcos(\theta)$$

where $$\theta=\frac{(2k-1)\pi}{2N},\quad k=1:N$$

2. Given the desired f_{c}, find analog frequency F_{c}. As we’ll show in the next section, the bilinear transform does not map the analog frequency F to discrete frequency f linearly. To achieve a digital filter cut-off frequency of f_{c}, the analog prototype cut-off frequency must be:

$$F_c=\frac{f_s}{\pi}tan\left(\frac{\pi f_c}{f_s}\right)$$

This exercise is called frequency pre-warping. For example, if f_{s}= 100 Hz and we want f_{c}= 20 Hz, then F_{c} = 23.13 Hz.

3. Scale the s-plane poles by 2πF_{c}. The poles obtained in step 1 gave Ω_{c} = 1 rad/s (i.e. 1/(2π) Hz). Multiplying the poles by 2πF_{c} scales the analog filter cut-off frequency to F_{c} and the digital filter cut-off frequency to f_{c}.

4. Transform the poles from the s-plane to the z-plane using the bilinear transform. From equation 3,

$$p_k=\frac{1+p_{ak}/(2f_s)}{1-p_{ak}/(2f_s)},\quad k=1:N$$

5. Add N zeros at z = -1. Following the example of equation 4, the numerator of H(z) is (z + 1)^{N} , meaning there are N poles at z = -1. We now can write H(z) as:

$$H(z)=K\frac{(z+1)^N}{(z-p_0)(z-p_1)...(z-p_{N-1})}\qquad(6)$$

In butter_synth, we represent the N zeros as a vector q= -ones(1,N).

6. Convert poles and zeros to polynomials with coefficients a_{n} and b_{n}. If we expand the numerator and denominator of equation 6, we get polynomials in z^{-n}:

$$H(z)=K\frac{b_0+b_1z^{-1}+...+b_Nz^{-N}}{1+a_1z^{-1}+...+a_Nz^{-N}}\qquad(7)$$

The Matlab code to perform the expansion is:

a= poly(p) a= real(a) b= poly(q)

We want H(z) to have a gain of 1 at ω= 0. Letting z= e^{jω}, we have z= 1. Then, referring to equation 7, we have gain at ω= 0 of:

$$H(z=1)=K\frac{\sum b}{\sum a}$$

So, for gain of 1 at ω= 0, we make $K=\sum a/\sum b$.

And that's the last step. Figure 3 shows the frequency response vs.
order N for filters synthesized by butter_synth. Figure 4 shows the impulse response vs. order
N for three cases.

Figure 3. IIR Butterworth magnitude responses for f_{c}= 10 Hz and f_{s}= 100 Hz.

[h,f]= freqz(b,a,256,fs); H= 20*log10(abs(h));<\pre>

Figure 4. IIR Butterworth impulse responses for fc = 1 kHz and fs = 32 kHz.

x= [1 zeros(1,95)]; % impulse y= filter(b,a,x); % impulse response

## Frequency Mapping of the Bilinear Transform

The bilinear transform does not map the continuous frequency F to discrete frequency f linearly. To show this, we evaluate equation 2 for s= jΩ and z= e^{jω}:

$$j\Omega=2f_s\frac{1-e^{-j\omega}}{1+e^{-j\omega}}$$

$$j\Omega=j2f_stan(\omega/2)$$

Now substitute Ω= 2πF and ω= 2πf/f_{s}:

$$F=\frac{f_s}{\pi}tan\left(\frac{\pi f}{f_s}\right)\qquad(8)$$

Figure 5 plots equation 8 for fs= 100 Hz. The entire analog frequency range maps to –f_{s}/2 to f_{s}/2. Also shown on the zoomed plot on the right is the transformation of discrete frequency f = 20 Hz to continuous frequency F = 23.13 Hz. Note that the frequency mapping is approximately linear for f < f_{s}/10 or so.

Figure 6 shows the effect of using equation 8 to pre-warp the cut-off frequency of an analog prototype filter to give f_{c} = 20 Hz. With pre-warping, the analog prototype poles were scaled by 2π*23.13_{. } Without pre-warping, they were scaled by 2π*20.

Figure 5. Frequency mapping of the bilinear transform for f_{s} = 100 Hz. x axis is discrete frequency and y-axis is continuous frequency. The right plot is a zoomed version of the left plot, showing the value of F for f = 20 Hz.

Figure 6. Effect of pre-warping for f_{c} = 20 Hz and f_{s} = 100 Hz. 5^{th} order IIR Butterworth.

## References

1. Mathworks website https://www.mathworks.com/help/signal/ref/butter.html

2. Oppenheim, Alan V. and Shafer, Ronald W., __Discrete-Time Signal Processing__, Prentice Hall, 1989, section 7.1.2

3. Lyons, Richard G., __Understanding Digital Signal Processing__, 2^{nd} Ed., Pearson, 2004, section 6.5

4. Williams, Arthur B. and Taylor, Fred J., __Electronic Filter Design Handbook__, 3^{rd} Ed., McGraw-Hill, 1995, section 2.3

5. Analog Devices Mini Tutorial MT-224, 2012 http://www.analog.com/media/en/training-seminars/tutorials/MT-224.pdf

Neil Robertson December 2017

## Appendix Matlab Function butter_synth (12 lines of code, excluding error check)

This program is provided as-is without any guarantees or warranty. The author is not responsible for any damage or losses of any kind caused by the use or misuse of the program.

% butter_synth.m 12/9/17 Neil Robertson % Find the coefficients of an IIR butterworth lowpass filter % using bilinear transform % % N= filter order % fc= -3 dB frequency in Hz % fs= sample frequency in Hz % b = numerator coefficients of digital filter % a = denominator coefficients of digital filter % function [b,a]= butter_synth(N,fc,fs); % if fc>=fs/2; error('fc must be less than fs/2') end % I. Find poles of analog filter k= 1:N; theta= (2*k -1)*pi/(2*N); pa= -sin(theta) + j*cos(theta); % poles of filter with cutoff = 1 rad/s % % II. scale poles in frequency Fc= fs/pi * tan(pi*fc/fs); % continuous pre-warped frequency pa= pa*2*pi*Fc; % scale poles by 2*pi*Fc % % III. Find coeffs of digital filter % poles and zeros in the z plane p= (1 + pa/(2*fs))./(1 - pa/(2*fs)); % poles by bilinear transform q= -ones(1,N); % zeros % % convert poles and zeros to polynomial coeffs a= poly(p); % convert poles to polynomial coeffs a a= real(a); b= poly(q); % convert zeros to polynomial coeffs b K= sum(a)/sum(b); % amplitude scale factor b= K*b;

- Comments
- Write a Comment Select to add a comment

Thanks Neil,

You cleared up the internal secrets of Matlab function "butter" and I got identical results using either. Great job and very useful.

Kaz,

Yes, I was pleasantly surprised when I ran the function and the results matched. So now only another 99.9% of Matlab is a black box.

Neil

Hi Sir,

Clarity in your articles while dealing with fundamental concepts is great.

Really helpful.

Thank you,

Sreekanth

Sreekanth,

You're welcome, I appreciate the feedback.

Neil

I request you to do one article like this on iir notch filter (if you have time).

Sreekanth

I'll put that on my list!

Neil

Hey there,

When I started looking for an algorithm to design Butterworth filter I wanted to escape a somewhat bug or limitation from matlab keeping me from designing filter with superlow cutt-off frequency, for instance by running the following code:

butter(2,1e-9);

It seems going too low does not do well with Matlab, supprinsingly your code also does not work with such cut-off frequency, do you have any idea what might cause that?

Cheers and thanks again for your work

Dermiste,

See my article on iir filter design using Cascaded biquads. It explains the problem you are having.

Regards,

Neil

All right it seems to be a solution although my filter is of order 2, and regardless the method (Biquad or Butter) I always end up having a gain K of 0 when summing my coefs "a". For the record I need a cut-off frequency at 2.365968869395443e-09.

I guess the improved narrowband you talk about in another article will do the trick? I am about to give it a try.

Thanks for you work !

That is a *really* low cut-off frequency. What is your application?

Note that you could use a decimator (e.g. CIC decimator) to reduce your sample rate and make the problem more tractable.

regards,

Neil

The application is DC value extraction with lowest noise possible. It is means to be implemented on GS/s ADC at a low power requirement.

Maybe I'm not approaching this the right way, I should filter smarter instead of harder (with butterworth 2nd order filter)

To post reply to a comment, click on the 'reply' button attached to each comment. To post a new comment (not a reply to a comment) check out the 'Write a Comment' tab at the top of the comments.

Registering will allow you to participate to the forums on ALL the related sites and give you access to all pdf downloads.